Did you ever try to imagine what our world will be like in the year 2050? While watching the news last night, I asked myself the question and, not surprisingly, my thoughts quickly led to – what else…our bone health. Even though increasingly negative news about osteoporosis drugs keeps popping-up in the media, we really don’t know what the long-term outcome will be. In other words, will doctors still prescribe osteoporosis medicines in the future?
With that in mind, I came up with two imaginary opposing scenarios for the year 2050, as reflected in a news broadcast. One is where the “cure” of osteoporosis and osteopenia revolves around prescription drugs, similar to nowadays. The second scenario pictures a world where everyone manages their health in a natural and drug-free way.
Oh! And please don’t forget that what you’re about to read is ONLY the product of my imagination. So join me on a time travel trip to the year 2050…
Here’s the first scenario
BREAKING NEWS
Good news for those diagnosed with osteoporosis. Pharmaceutical giant Profit & Gamble announced today that the FDA has finally approved their new drug Cementex to treat advanced osteoporosis. Dee Seat, a spokesperson for the company, told WBS News this morning that “we are thrilled to launch our latest drug that will help millions afflicted with osteoporosis, a crippling and potentially deadly disease. Thanks to Cementex, we can guarantee to both women and men a fracture-free future”.
Unlike current osteoporosis treatments, Cementex requires only one dose that will last a lifetime. It is injected directly into the bones under light sedation, and the whole procedure typically takes no more than a couple of hours.
Ms. Seat went on to explain that reported side-effects are negligible: “The most common side effect is stiffening of the joints, which happens when Cementex leaks out to the cartilage and joints, affecting mostly the knees, elbows and fingers. We can cure osteoporosis, but unfortunately, we can’t fight gravity…yet.”
Doctors can easily treat this side-effect and the occasional pain by prescribing Dieoxx , a new drug developed by Quirck & Co..WBS was not able to reach anyone at Quirck to get more information on this drug.
Ms. Seat also confirmed that Cementex is covered by Mediscare, and that the first one thousand patients will receive a $200 discount coupon toward the purchase of a wheelchair, compliments of Profit & Gamble.
Stay tuned because when we come back, we’ll show you the latest umbrella designs that are stylish and give you 100% protection from acid rain…
Here’s the second scenario
BREAKING NEWS
TNN just got news that pharmaceutical giant Quirck & Co. filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy protection. Quirck is one more casualty added to the long list of prescription drug manufacturers that have had trouble with the dwindling demand for their products.
“We regret that this is yet one more drug producer that has failed” said Roland Paulman, a spokesman for the privately owned Health and Human Services Marketing, Inc., “but consumers are staying away from the type of drugs they manufacture”. He went on to comment that “This is further proof that our aggressive Just Say No to Prescription Drugs campaign continues to show great results. Ultimately, patients make their own decisions, and the trend clearly points to an ever increasing choice of natural supplements and herbal remedies.”
We were not able to reach anyone at Quirck & Co. However, TNN’s financial sources told us that it’s been long known that Preventive Medicine was taking a big bite out of the now doomed company’s profits. In the last twenty years osteoporosis, arthritis, heart ailments, and diabetes, to name a few, have literally become a thing of the past.
Among the sector’s biggest gainers is Natural Supplements, Inc. Upon hearing Quirck’s filing, investors rushed to purchase Natural’s shares causing an unprecedented rally. Our financial correspondent at the New York Stock Exchange reports that Natural Supplement’s shares have gone up by more than 5% in today’s trading session.
When we come back, we’ll interview Dee Tocks, the owner of Stay Healthy Walk-in Centers, a nationwide franchise. You won’t believe what she has to say about the reduced visit prices starting next month, and she’ll reveal who qualifies for the new Stay Healthy mail-in rebate.
Whoa! Back to reality now
Stay healthy!
Vivian
We value your privacy and will never share your information with anyone.
November 17, 2009
Thanks for all your help. I was diagnosed with osteopenia and the Dr. gave me calcitonin salmon nasal spray. I took it for 4 days–then I had severe burning and pain (urinary)when going to the bathroom. I quit taking it, and the burning cleared up. However, all the surrounding tissues had become inflammed and I had pain for another month. I had to use hydrocortizone cream to clear up that problem. It was awful! About that time I stumbled across your website and I now eat differently, exercise more, take strontium and other bone building vitamins. I informed the Dr. I will not take any of those drugs again. I am hoping for good bone density numbers next time.
November 14, 2009
I am 48 years old and diagnosed with osteoperosis in one of my hips. I took Actonel and had very severe chest pain and muscle aches. I decided I would not take another drug for that!! After 2 months I no longer feel the side effects.
I am post menopausel at a younger age than most , I think. What are my chances of losing more bone density than the normal age of menopause?? I guess I feel like my life has been shortened by 10 years. I started perimenopause @39 . Anything I can do other than drugs.?
November 9, 2009
Vivian: I enjoyed your humor and all your emails. I am studying your book and trying to follow the 80/20 plan but am not sure I’m getting it just right and it is hard as I cook for my husband in the old way. I often eat a little of what I fix for him and add more veggies and fruits for myself. Have tried some of your recipies and would like more. I want to try the carrot cake recipe you sent. What I am particularly thrilled about is that the diet has been so helpful with my digestive problems. I am also seeing a naturopath and take a lot of nutritional supplements. She does wonder why you recommend light olive oil. I mostly use virgin olive oil and some other good oils. The only supplement that you recommend that I don’t take is Vitamin K as I read it is plentiful in fruits and veggies. I am 75 and was recently diagnosed with osteoporosis in hip area with a T-Score of -2.6. Spine -1.5. The doctor nearly had me scared into taking Actonel but decided that I was more scared of the side effects. I do not take any prescription drugs but have in the past. I took Prepro for about l2 years but have been off of it for several years. I do have some other questions but don’t want to make this too long. I was going to mention that I take MSM capsules for my knees which I get at Walmart. I take 1000 mm twice a day plus another mixture containing 750 mm of MSM. This saved me from orthoscoptic knee surgury a few years ago. I do have a torn meniscus in one knee but they feel fine except for some stiffness. I do walk every day about 2 miles but need to do more for my upper body which is jelly. I am fairly thin at this point weighing about l33 and am nearly 5′7″. Thank you, Vivien and God Bless You. Love, Esther
November 8, 2009
Loved the scenatios. I fervently hope that the second is the more accurate vision. I am more and more convinced that we are all guinea pigs in the great pharmaceutical bottom line frenzy. I know I asked my doctor about the side effects of Altace, a drug I take for High Blood Pressure. She assured me that all drugs have side effects, I always thought that physicians were boound first of all to do no harm. There is something terribly wrong in the practice of medicine today. Paternalism and maternalism has no place in doctor/patient relations.
November 6, 2009
Vivian, I am reading the information that you send, and I am thinking about what I want to do. I see an endocrinologist soon, and I will continue to look at all options. I do appreciate the information that you are sending. I have been on Actonel for a long time, along with calcium and vitamin D. I have to take a B12 supplement, because my B12 was very low. My vitamin D is low, and my bones have gotten worse over the last two years, so you can see why I’m looking at my options. What I am doing does not seem to be working. Thank you!
November 2, 2009
Vivian, great message! Yes, it has been a couple of months since I got into “save our bones” and I am truly enjoying every piece of info you put on the e-mail. I just re-read your entire book,”Save our Bones” Revolution and am trying hard to stick to your advice. No soda and drinking distilled water for the last 2 months and working hard at eating the 80/20 alkaline vs acidity foods. It is sometimes hard to follow when invited out to dinner but am making much better food choices. I’ve tried a couple of your receipes and love them!
Keep up the great work! I am sure that in years to come more women will go the “drug-free” way to increasing bone density.
Terry
October 24, 2009
Vivian,
I continue to find encouragement in reading your e-mails and your book on The Bone Heath Revolution. Please keep up your research on the natural way to keep our bones strong.
October 24, 2009
I’m on a senior income and can not afford [i'm sure, very informative] books.Sorry.But your emails are appreciated.
thanks
E.T.
October 20, 2009
I loved your article and believe that in a few years people will realize that a healthy diet, exercise and some good supplements will prove better than drugs and all their side affects!
Keep up the great job, the encouragement and very informative e-mails….they are important in keeping me on track with “save our bones” program. THANK YOU!!
Terry
October 20, 2009
You hit it on the head, Vivian!
As we head towards an even more-highly-populated future and a loss of
natural resources, I think you’re seeing it realistically. It’s scary to imagine the perspectives of future generations as the world becomes aimed toward digital/less natural thinking with a greater loss of human thought! Let’s make sure people stay healthy because of good thinkers, not drugs – thanks for setting a terrific path for them!
October 19, 2009
Hi Vivian, I have your book and I’m a little confused I was charged $101.95. when I thought the book was only $47.00. Yes, I have Osteoporosis level 2. I’m in fairly good health.
But I confused following your diet I’m 66 years old and 5′2” and only 99 lbs and on thyroid drug of 50mg and I’m also hypoglycemic. and still have hot-flashes.
Will following this diet cause me to lose more weight. which I can’t afford to lose any more weight. I don’t understand the eating diet of the Alkaline vs Acidyfing foods. How can the body function with any protein from some meats. which I’m not a big meat eater. only fish- sardine- chicken breast-turkey. I have start juicing my fruits and vegetables.
I would appreciate your advice.
Mary from TEXAS
October 17, 2009
Vivian, I am just starting to read your Bone Health Revolution Book which is very interesting and very informative. From the time my doctor prescribed Fosamax for Osteoporosis, I knew that I did not want to take any more drugs especially a drug that was as harmful as Fosamax. Thanks to the internet which provides many avenues of investigation, I read nothing positive about this drug and expressed my concern to my doctor who continued to recommend it as my only choice. I already have joint problems (osteoarthritis) and have had jaw problems (gritting my teeth). Therefore, due to the problems many were having, this was definitely not an option for me.
Doing investigation into the use of Fosamax on the internet and the desire for natural alternatives, was how I found your website. I was just recently diagnosed with osteoporosis (-2.6 in my hip and Osteopenia in my back). I am trying to be more conscious of the food that I eat and the exercise alternatives which may benefit me (I have arthritis in both of my knees and some loss of cartilage in both knees).
I also found a website = http://www.algaecal.com/algaecal-clinical-study.html which talks about the Algae Cal Program which is designed to grow bone. I have just recently started on this program which is an all natural program which naturally contains large quantities of calcium and magnesium, and 73 trace minerals and other plant nutrients which through several clinical studies have proven their importance in slowing bone loss and increasing bone mineral density. If taken as directed the AlgaeCal Plus supplement would provide per serving 720 mg of Calcium, 350 mg. magnesium, Trace Minerals 1464 mg, Boron 3 mg, Vitamin D3 1600 IU, Vitamin K2 100mcg, Vitamin C 50mg. Recommended: 4 capsules per day. Also recommended is Strontium Boost Supplement which has 2230 mg of Strontium Citrate per serving. Recommended: 3 capsules per day.
Have you or anyone else heard of this? Finally, keep sending your e-mails. They are really informative and helpful. Hopefully, some day there will be an all natural product that is guaranteed to wipe out osteoporosis completely and that doctors will agree to give their patients. There are currently so many harmful drugs out there. Thanks for all you do to give people other alternatives for treatment.
Janice
October 17, 2009
Hello Vivian:
I remain very impressed and interested in your presentation of your studies and your practice.
I’ve had an interest in my bone density for years. I was in an automobile accident in 1969 that resulted in right ankle fractures as well as facial damage resulting from impact causing nasal cartilege and left cheek puncture. Aside from the damage my right ankle, I had fractures and was bedridden for a few weeks. I didn’t have broken bones (just fractures) but I had nasal cartilege loss and my left cheek was puntured. This accident took place
42 years ago. I have had ankle swelling and daily swelling that I take over the counter
arthritis medication for daily. I still dance, sail in the summer and hike the woods until it’s too cold. I’m cautious but concerned about my right leg as the bones don’t appear to be thinning but my musculature is significantly less below my right knee. I know that there’s some bone loss in my leg. Dr’s are somewhat but not overly concerned about my anke but only suggest that I wear an elastic brace of sorts. My Dr at Yale New Haven wants to set me up with a brace (this week in fact). I intend to turn down the offer because I think I do ok with some support but the contraption that he measured me for seems overdone if not totally unnecessary. My other Dr recommended and set me up for Boniva because another Dr reported that I had some loss of bone density. Aside from all this verbiage,I remain active and think that exercise is fundamental and important to continue as long as my bones remain reasonably strong.
I remain very impressed and interested in your study and dedication to your presentation of information. I have shared copies with a close friend. I respect your practice and your updated study of bone density. I’ll continue to be interested in your study and receiving the information that you’ve presented.
I am a social worker, presently unemployed and looking forward to working again. Let’s stay in touch. Sincerely, Charis Lockwood
October 19, 2009
I am a senior, still very active, however, fixed income – cannot buy any books. Also some
of material you send will not come up on my
computer.
October 17, 2009
Dear Vivian, I have just read all these letters from people who sent them to you.Could you tell me whats the difference between Osteoporosis and osteoarthitus.I am always in pain and am on one pain med.sometimes it works sometimes it dont.I just recieved a back brace today. sometimes there is much pain ini my6 knee but not all the time.My dr. is going to be sending me for another cat scan and a MRI, i think it has progressed.I find reading your materal very interesting and informative.money is very tight right now but eventually i hope to get the book. thank you for sharing your information, God bless you, Merry
October 16, 2009
I’m glad I signed up to get your information. I read every bit of it.
I have Osteopenia which is……. well, you know what it is. I am very
afraid of taking drugs, and that’s why I research it and found you.
I am very sensitive to drugs and try not to take any, just vitamins.
Thank you for your information.
October 14, 2009
Even though this is supposed to be “hyupothetical”–it totally rings true. I am so thankful for being off Fosamax for a year (yes, I took it for SIX!!) and for knowing about eating alkaline and for my weight vest and for Vitamin D. And I’m also thankful for all the information that you give us, Vivian, because it is so encouraging and because it’s true. I look forward to your messages and save them all. I just wish I’d known about this, seven years ago!
October 14, 2009
Vivian, I am reading your Bone Health Revolution Book which is very interesting and really makes alot of sense with a natural approach to help osteoporosis rather than drugs. I was diagnosed with osteoporosis 3 years ago and have been taking fosamax since then until July of this year when I stopped after doing research on the drug and looking for other options. I am trying to follow your book as best I can along with doing weight bearing exercises and taking calcium and a multivitamin. I don’t like the idea of taking drugs so your book has really helped me make a choice. Thank you.
Lorraine
October 14, 2009
My mother had a terrible case of Osteo to the point she was in constant pain and her ribs would break and she was unable to walk. I have a terrible fear that I may end up like her. I have been taking Foximax for five years with no noticeable side effects. I am hesitant to drop it cold turkey as I am afraid my body will just start having fractures.
The other day I went for my pap smear and the little booties had Foximax written on them. I know this is a lot of hipe for the drug companies but I have such a fear of becomming bed ridden. I do take E, D, calcium, fish oil, and many other vitamins and have only had a few painful experiences where I reached for something and strained a bone somewhere and was in pain for a week or so.
How can I be sure you are right and my doctor is wrong??? I have seen this disease at its worst, my mother had the hump in her back and lived in constant pain.
Georgia
October 13, 2009
I do read yr comments on osteoporosias, very
informative and also have yr book that I have
shared with a couple of ladies. Latest info
I just read is also interesting, but 2050 is a
long way off.
October 13, 2009
The way things are going I think the fist scanario is what will happen in the future.
My dream would be the second scanario.
Thanks Soili
October 13, 2009
Vivan:
I don’t hasve osteoporosis I just wante to learn about it.
Betty
October 13, 2009
HELLO VIVIAN. I REALLY APPRECIATED ALL THE INFORMATION YOU HAVE GIVEN US IN YOUR BOOK. SINCE I GOT IT I STARTED WHAT I CALLED IT THE DIET 80/20 AND ALL THE OTHERS RECOMMENDATION FROM YOUR BOOK. SOMETIMES WHEN I GO TO A RESTAURANT I DON’T FOLLOW IT PROPERLY BUT I HOPE IT DOESN’T AFFECT THE RESULTS. I’M ANXIOUS THE TIME PASS TO HAVE THE DENSITOMETRY DONE WHICH WILL BE PLANNED FOR NEXT JANUARY.
I REALLY TRUST IN YOUR NATURAL METHOD SO I’LL KEEP YOU INFORM ABOUT THE RESULTS.
October 11, 2009
Hi Vivian, Thank you for all your information. I have been reading the bone health book. Iam doing the best I can on the 80/20 diet. I also started my weight bearing exercises at the gym.I have osteoporis in my left hip,the Dr. put me on calcitonin salmon nasal spray.My cardio Dr.said no to all the other drugs because I have a history of a-fib. I went off the nasal spray two weeks ago after reading your book. My hips,knees,ankles ached after stopping the drug for about a week. Could that be side affects? I only took the nasal spray for one month.I also take thyroxine for my thyroid and a simvastatin. Are these drugs going to affect the rebuilding of my bones? I really appreciate all your help. Carol my
October 7, 2009
Great website, and very helpful. I’m off Boniva now and eagerly reading and attempting to follow your program. Thanks so much.
Sondra
October 9, 2009
I am so glad I purchased your book.6 weeks into the 8 to 2 diet
and Iam beginning to feel less pain
in my upper back.The recepies are great and my husband likes them also. I even have a little more
energy.I thank God I found you.My Dr. still pushes the Actonel. But
I will never take them.
Thank you,
Regards
Karin Kestler
October 4, 2009
Vivian, thank you so much for your e-mails. I ordered the Bone Revolution book and am doing my best to follow your advice regarding the alkaline and acid balance of 80/20. Also, enjoyed the two articles which I think are right on.
I was diagnosed with osteoporosis six and a half years ago and was prescribed Actonel which I took for five and a half years. There were many side effects which my GP would not acknowledge were caused by the Actonel. One side effect which I have never heard anyone else address was a chronic cough. It was almost unbearable. GP treated me for acid reflux, asthma and angina pectoris before finally referring me to a cardiologist. The cardiologist could find nothing wrong with my heart after many tests and suggested I discontinue the Actonel for a month to see if that could be causing my cough. My GP was not happy with this suggestion and referred me to a pulmonary specialist. The pulmonary specialist could find nothing in my lungs that would cause me to cough. She said to stay off the Actonel for now and see if that helped. It has been almost six months now since I have taken an Actonel and I have almost stopped coughing completely.
Now, I do not know about my bones but I feel great and can walk again for almost an hour each day which I was not able to do. I will never go back on the Actonel as I am sure that was the problem. I am trusting diet, supplements and exercise to keep my bones strong.
I know this comment is long and poorly written but I am so happy to know that others think the same way I do about the drugs and I thank them for their comments and thank you, Vivian for all the good work you do for all of us.
October 3, 2009
Thank you for the information you send us. I took Actenol for about three or four years. I stopped taking it about a year or two ago and July 8, 2009 I fractured my spine. It has been a painful ordeal and I am still in pain. The doctor said that when you have osteoporosis that is one of the areas that can fracture easily. I thought after taking the Actenol I would be ok but apparently not.
Thank you again,
Lupe
October 3, 2009
Hi Vivian,
I am enjoying your emails and your book and have for sometime been using herbs prescribed by a Naturopath as opposed to always running to the doctor and getting prescriptiond filled. All those chemicals, ugh!
I also carefully read the ingredients on packages of food and tend not to buy prepared food but rather make meals from fresh food and produce grown close to home.
I am using the Wellness belt and the wrist and ankle weights and will be geting into the diet shortly.
Your scenarios were very interesting and I hope that it plays out sooner than later for the health of all mankind.
October 2, 2009
Thank you so much Vivian. You are so helpful with the information. Those drugs the doctor prescribe have a lot of side affects. I have a sister-in-law that believes ever thing the doctor tells her and more. She is on these drugs. I will see what happens to her in the future. So far I have not taken these drugs for bones. Years ago but did not take them long. Thanks to your book and also herbs so far so good. Thanks again Vivian.
Alberta
September 25, 2009
Interesting to say the least. I don’t remember anything about Vitamin D prescription in any of your material so far. That is the one you need to be warning people about. I have a fat folder on it, unfortunately.
September 26, 2009
What’s wrong with taking Vitamin D?
October 11, 2009
yES i HAVE commented on that(vitD) It is also very important for your immune system . I would get colds that would take ages to go away especially the nazel gunk but now think it was to do with vit d being very low.
September 21, 2009
Great scenarios. I believe in preventive medicine. I feel Dr.’s are to quick to prescribe drugs instead of getting to the route of the problem. I have healthy bones and want to keep them that way. Thanks for all your information.
September 20, 2009
Thank you for all the information. I have read all that you have sent me. I was diagnosed with Osteopena in August of this year and my doctor did not want to prescribe Boniva or any of those other drugs. She expressed her concerns about the side effects and instead put me on Calcium and Vitamin D. I know that doctors usually try to push these drugs; therefore, I feel very blessed to have a doctor who truly cares about her patients. Please continue sending the e-mails. I would like to order your book sometime in the near future.
Thank you.
Gladys
September 19, 2009
I like your second scenario, but am afraid it will take much longer to get Americans to believe that natural is the best way. I was diagnosed with Osteoporosis a year ago, at 49. I took the Fosomax, and began having pain almost immediately. I thought it was because my bones were bad. Six months into it, I began spacing my doses because the burning in my chest was so bad. Nine months into it, I looked in the mirror and had no eyebrow. My web search revealed that this can be a rare side effect. The pain in my back, hips, thighs and wrists was so bad that I had a hard time standing from a sitting position. I had begun to become sedontary, which is quite unlike me. I quit the Fosomax and ordered your book. The next week I went to the dentist who found my jaw bone is dying, and he could find no reason as my hygiene is perfect. The book arrived, and I tested my Ph. I was off the charts! I began the diet, and adjusted my vitamins and supplements as suggested. Ph is now normal and I’m active again! I’ll see what the doctor has to say in two weeks, but I’m NEVER taking those drugs again. Sally Fields should be ashamed!
September 19, 2009
Dear Vivan, I do appreciate all your emails and your book on bone health. I had been taking alendronate for about a year. My knees were really getting to be painful. The doctor said I was walking bone on bone and I would need knee replacements. After reading your book I stopped taking alendronate and have been on the 80/20 diet. The left knee had nerve pain all the way down to the top of my foot. The pain has gone in the left leg, however, I still have alot of pain in the right knee. I can’t do stand up exercise because of the pain. When I walk the pain shoots up to my hip.
The doctor gave me 3 shots of synvisc directly into the knee. That was 1 shot per week. I am hesitant to get knee replacements. I need to lose some weight before it can happen. In the meanwhile , I am following your suggestions with the diet. I find losing the weight is difficult with this diet. Do you have any suggestions? In the meanwhile, I look forward to your emails with all your ideas and helpful aids. Thank you for all your hard work.
September 18, 2009
Do you have a list of recipies and meal plans for us to follow?
September 17, 2009
your book is an answered prayer; I am reading it for the second time and taking alot of notes. The 80%-20% is fabulous . . . I feel better health-wise just doing that. I love your encouraging emails and since I grew up in Ft. Lauderdale, I feel like we are alot alike.
My husband brought me to God’s country, Knoxville, TN – it really is closer to Heaven up here.
THANK you so much for caring for our bones and sharing your wisdom with all of us . . . we really appreciate you.
God Bless you !
September 15, 2009
Loved your look into the future but I hope it comes sooner rather than later. Lets hope the medical profession really gets involved on our side
September 11, 2009
FINISHED READING YOUR BOOK AND I FIND IT VERY HELPFUL, ALTHOUGH KEEPING VERY BUSY AND KIND OF CONFUSED WITH ALL THE VITAMINS ETC. I AM DOING MY BEST TO CONVINCE MY DAUGHTER …HOWEVER SHE IS NOT INTERESTED. I DONT THINK SHE HAS STARTED THE MEDS. PERHAPS SHE IS GIVING IT A LOT OF THOUGHT (HOPEFULLY) THANKS AND GOOD LUCK.
RONNIE
October 5, 2009
If anyone is interested in selling me their book, please contact me. I have seriously limited funds, and cannot even afford supplements at this time. I appreciate anyone who can help me. Thank you so much
October 14, 2009
Write to me. I think I can help you out. Put ‘Vivian’s book’ in the subject line.
September 10, 2009
Hi Vivian,
Although ‘tongue in cheek’, your choice of ‘company names’ reflects a reality that is disturbing. Profit is put before people and I am sure that the drug companies would not publish drug information unless they had to. Reading the list of possible side effects has led me to ignore my last prescription and concentrate on an alkaline diet. I feel better for it and look forward to a postitve result from the next bone density scan.
Thanks Vivian.
John
September 10, 2009
Dear Vivian
Thank you for your latst message, a really brilliant spoof (I hope) on the future. It made me smile but, of course it is not funny.
You say I haven’t contacted you. Well I have sent you the odd email. But what I would like to say here is that I do appreciate all your messages and I am taking it all to heart and putting it into practice, especially giving up the Fosemax.
I am feeling very well and I am sure my bones are doing well, though I don’t have a scan till next year.
Thank you for you wonderful work. Best wishesJune
September 10, 2009
Dear vivian I have sne tyou several apreciative messages but am not sure you got them.
In case it didn’t work, I am basically saying please carry on sending me news of osteoporosis – I take in all the tips and am doing fine.
September 6, 2009
Thanks Vivian,
I enjoyed your interpretation of what might eventuate in the future and had a bit of a smile when reading the company names!
I am currently taking Protos 2G (Strontium Ranelate), prescribed by my physican, after a previous Drug did not show any improvement from the last BMD. Naturally I am weaning myself off this drug whilst changing my eating & exercise habits.
My age & sex (52yr old male) proves Osteoporosis does not just effect older women!
Thanks again,
Brian.
September 5, 2009
Hi Vivian:
I loved your latest email of looking into the future. I don’t think its too far into fantasy. I do hope the second email is what really comes about. Thank you so much for sending emails to us to keep us informed. I really look forward to reading and finding any information that I can to protect my bone health. I do everything that I can to be healthy.
Thanks
Kathy
September 5, 2009
I loved it! So clever. I only hope that the second scenario will happen sooner! (:
September 3, 2009
Vivian,
You are so wonderful to care for people as you do. I haven’t bought your book yet as money is worse than tight presently.
A month ago I was diagnosed with my hips at -2.5 and my spine at -2.6 with a fracture already. I refused fosamax and forteo. I know how amazingly the body will respond if we will even do just a little to help it. I have not slowed down as I think that would be the worst thing to do. I walk and use my ab lounger to strengthen the muscles in my back so they can support my bones until I can build them back. I research the cause of osteoporosis and found I ate mostly acid foods so I am changing that, also.
You give me hope that I really can build my bones back.
Thank You!!
August 30, 2009
Dear Vivian,
It is hard to predict the future (I wish I could), but I hope that more and more people will increasingly take the time and trouble to do their own research regarding their daily regimen and health care decisions instead of blindly leaving everything up to their physicians. Doctors write prescriptions for a living and we, as patients, need to examine other possible (natural) alternatives to the harmful drugs, most with devistating short and long term side effects, that are so casually pushed off on all of us by doctors.
I wish I could look into the future and see most, if not all, of the drug companies forced out of business because of overwhelming numbers of people following a healthy life style of sound nutrition and regular exercise. Unfortunatley, a lot of people still think it is easier to continue eating their twinkies and chips and then take pills when they develop chronic illness.
I have increased my weight bearing exercises as I believe that the bones have no choice but to step up if the corresponding muscle structure requires it. I believe that along with a proper alkaline diet and supplements, that my bones will respond positively and restructure and rebuild in a normal, natural way.
Thank you for your correspondence, Vivian. It is always good to hear from you.
Sincerely,
Andrea
August 29, 2009
HI, I AM IN THE POSITION LIKE ALL THE OTHERS, MY DOCTOR PUT ME ON ACTONEL BECAUSE SHE SAID I AM GOING TO BREAK ONE OF THESE DAYS, BUT I STOPPED 2 YEARS AGO ON MY OWN. WHEN I WENT, LAST MONTH, FOR MY ANNUAL CHECKUP SHE WAS VERY ANGRY AT ME AND MORE SO WHEN SHE GOT THE RESULTS OF MY BONEDENSITY TEST, SHE SAID I AM 10 % LESS.BUT I TOLD HER I WILL NOT GO BACK TO DRUGS, SHE SAID EXSERCISE ALONE WONT DO ANYTHING. I DO NOT BELIEVE IN THAT AND I WILL CONTINUE ON MY OWN. I HAVE A QUESTION FOR YOU: I EAT MACROBIOTIC HOW CAN I COMBINE THE FOODS , SINCE YOU SAY THAT GRAINS ARE MOST ACIDIC? DO YOU HAVE A SUGGESTION ON THAT HOW TO RECONCILE THE TWO? I DO NOT LIKE MEATS AT ALL, BUT ILOVE MY FRUIT, VEGGIES AND MY GRAINS? ARE THERE ANY GRAINS BETTER THAT OTHERS? I TAKE ALL KINDS OF GOOD SUPPLEMENTS. BY THE WAY I AM 57.
THANKYOU, HOPING TO HEAR FROM YOU SOON
JOSEPHINE
September 14, 2009
I’d like to see an answer to this!
August 27, 2009
Vivian,
Since reading your book, I have shared the information with many of my friends and family. I have shared my book and your website to try an inform them that these drugs are not doing what the pharmaceutical companies say they should. My mother,who is 81, fell and broke her hip and femur. She needed two pins in her hip and a plate and 6 screws in her femur. Needless to say she was on Fosamax. Two weeks prior to her fall, I told her about your book and suggested that she stopped talking Fosamax, which she did discontinue. Of course, it was too late for her. She does take coral calcium and vitamin D. It is amazing that our doctors who we entrused our lives with, are informing us incorrectly. What will it take to get these drugs off the market? I took Boniva for 6 months and did not like the side affects. I told my doctor I wanted to discontinue the drug. Then I stumbled uon your book and know I made the right decision!!!! Thanks!
August 26, 2009
Hi, Vivian
The information from Save Our Bones motivated me to look further into alternatives to the Actonel my physician prescribed when she gave me the diagnosis of Osteopenia. Thanks to you and other excellent material I found on the web (see http://www.Melioguide.com, for example) I booked an appointment with my family doctor to discuss the natural alternatives…and she agreed to give me a year to NOT take Actonel….but to take the healthy supplements, to change how I eat to move my body toward alkaline balance, and to be doing weight bearing and strength exercises with bonafide support. It took courage to make that appointment, but my doctor and I are on the same page now. Thanks for your commitment to support healthy alternatives to drugs! Hopefully the Health Care Reform in the USA will include more paths to wellness. I’ve been sharing this information with others! Nancy
August 25, 2009
dear Vivian: just a footnote to the last comment
I am currently retrieving your letters out of our j-mail and transferring them into our medical folder. So don’t despair, all is not lost!! (yet!!)
R.P.Mez
August 25, 2009
dear Vivian: I really only contacted you on behalf of my wife, Joanne F. Mez, who would be the one benefiting from your letters, providing
she doesn’t get bombarded with them as I am. She has stopped taking the Ost. drugs some time ago, and is unfortunately way overboard into naturopathic and organic stuff, which is totally overpriced. Please re-direct all your comments to her so that I can put you on the contact list, which is currently not happening.
Thanks
R.P.Mez
August 23, 2009
Clever little piece. You’re probably right on!
August 17, 2009
Vivian, I just want to say ‘thank you’ for all the information about osteoporosis and osteopinea. It has been so helpful. Since learning more about this, I told my sister about the danger of ‘fosomax’. She was taking it for maybe a couple of years. She has now stopped taking it. She is eating a lot more wisely now and getting more exercise.
August 17, 2009
Thank you for the continued information. I save each and every article to read over often. Doing the same with the book as well and following the advice. Please keep the emails and articles coming.
Thanks so very much!
Celestina Marie
August 16, 2009
dear vivian,
i am 42 and just recently diagnosed with oa..im worried about it especially this coming winter.
i went to the doctor to ask what to do with it,but the dr said there is no drugs in treating it just take ibufropen or tylenol when its painful..i always read your natural tips and appreciate it.
i dont have credit card to able to buy books.i commend you on your will to help
August 7, 2009
Well i am doing ok. I went to the doctor for my pap test and they asked how i was doing with fosmax and i said good i am not taking it. I said (but it did not matter i was not taking it) what will the doctor say and she nothing and she said they really do not know that much about it. Duh. So i know there will be know issues when i see him next year and with all the materials i have to get through which are interesting and great i hope to have improved by next year. On my quest with talking with people who have had bad experience with and other who think they cannot live without it. So each his own all i can do is share. I mention to you about citracal plus bone density builder. I was taking 2 a day and I was telling my sister in law about it and she looked and read it is 4 a day. So one week i up to the 4 a day and woke up when went to bed with cramps in both leg and i thought what in the world is going on. I let this happen for a couple of day and i switch back to 2 a day and all was good again. It so happen that i got a email from a the citracal site on which i had sign up for a health challenge. At the end they let you down load at coupon but this time it did not and i had to call a # and got to talk to real person. I said i called because the coupon would not download but wanted to asks question anyway and told her my story. She very interested and surprised and asked a lot of question. She also called me back about 15 minutes late with some more question. But short of the story i like the product and believe and believe it or not i can tell a good difference in my teeth with taking 2 but cannot take 4 because of the cramps it cause with the 4. As soon as i went back to just taking 2 all is well again. But on to your info i am working on the 80/20% and what a shock that was to read. I am an eater but am not over weight but was interested in the combination of food. I have not had time to get to all the site you have as i am working hard on the information and reading the book. I have not changed my mind that doing it the healthy is not the wrong. One thing i was surprised at was about where blueberries feel in the list. Never ate a lot of blueberries but always heard they were so go and by chance this summer i have frozen 5 quarts this past month.I was pleased with watermelon love that fruit. Lot’s more to say but i want to work on the paper work and i believe it is the right thing and picked up the coQ10 50mg gelatin capsul softge capsule today. the only thing and the person at the store never heard of it was the words ubiquinol and ubiquinone. Did find it in the on the bottle. It was in the book i have and the new version that gnc has out. So all and all it has been an interesting day and i was thinking and talking about you and came home and here was your email. I am still progressing and thank you and will check out the site as i can get to them. 8/7/09
August 5, 2009
I amm holding fast against my dr.who keeps pushing boniva etc and now wants me to try Reclast.I am not going to use these drugs. I am looking for a better way.
August 2, 2009
I have read and dog-eared the Bone Health Revolution and have lists of foods from the book that are best for calcium intake hanging on my refrigerator. Lifting light weights and doing squats, etc. to strengthen the top of the femur where i have a -2.6 BMD. Took the FRAX test and came out still in the acceptable range, although my internist wants another Dexa this year and says “then we shall see”. She is determined to get me on Boniva. She was not a happy camper when I asked how can the osteoblasts build new bone when the osteoclasts are unable to leave!!! Loved your 2050 comments—Profit and Gamble, etc.! I’m sure you are right.
August 2, 2009
It sounds like you have a crystal ball, the way things are going, it just might be true. The drugs now are too “iffy” to use. I am trying to save for your book. Thanks for caring. Carole
August 2, 2009
The sad thing is your first story sound more like the real future. Until protocol changes were doctor’s aren’t afraid of being sued. Drug companies have so much money and no ethics. Doctor’s are so over booked that they have no time to teach wellness. The likely hood for your healthy bones, drug free and oh my, no fast food and soda for our over weight kids. But we can all have hope that one day when things get bad enough just maybe everyone will have an AH HA moment and start to get it. One day and one person at a time is a start. Thanks for all you do. Sherie
July 23, 2009
Hello Vivian,
Recently I had a very bad infection on my left arm from what we believed to be a spider bite. Doctor prescribed severall items and a potent antibiotic. Voila….it worked it’s wonders. But in reading the side effects very carefully we noticed that it said “do not take calcium with this medication” and the flags went up. I have been taking a once a week vitamin D pill and lots of calcium from our Roex company. Today my doctor asked me to do a colonoscopy and I told him no, that I was afraid of it because my past father in law had received one and they punctured the colon which ended his life some weeks later. My wife uses holistic and natural ways to take care of me. We don’t need the meds for everything. Thanks again for your wonderful book and all the rest.
July 20, 2009
i use natural remedies for everything, Vivian–only way to go.
i’m 88 and i just quit chasing girls last week when they finally outran me.
July 19, 2009
Read most of your e-mails, and for some odd reason I feel kind of alone, being that there doesn’t seem like too many people that are in my age range? Though it is great having others with the same problems and side affects that understand and can relate. I happened to experience on my first encounter with Boniva, the worst pain. On my first perscription, never again will I believe in those medications and Bluff Scare tactics that they want to put on your guilt…. I do appreciate all that I read and learn from everyone. Good Luck and God Bless everyone!!!
July 14, 2009
Dear Vivian…
Am enjoying your book “The Bone Health Revolution”, good common sense information. Also enjoy your site on my computer.
This is the truth: Last year my hips hurt so much I had to hold onto the railing going up the stairs. I read about flax seed oil being good for you. Looked it up and it said there were no side effects from it.
Tried it, and two weeks later, no pain in my hips and even though I don’t have to hold onto the stair railing, I do anyway for safety.
I cannot swallow pills, I get the liquid. I take one tablespoon every morning. I do this, plus follow all your great advice. Hope this discovery helps. I also take 2 calcium tablets and 1 baby aspirin daily.
Take a walk (short) every day, eat well & bowl twice a week. I am 78 and doing great…Thanks Vivian…
July 14, 2009
Hi Vivienne,
Thanks so much for your book which I read avidly and am trying to follow pretty much to the letter.
My doctor keeps on trying to force me to take these awful medications, and say that she wants me to have infusions as the pills have had adverse affects. I took one, and felt ill, so these were changed. I haven’t taken any since, but am continuing with self medicating which I had started before this ‘brainwashing’ that my bones are going to be so brittle, that my hips and spine are likely to break with any gentle tap!!!
I am a gardner and work long hours pulling, tugging, digging etc, etc, and feel fit and well and healthy. I have even fallen on my hips a couple of time when pulling and something suddenly gives and jump up fine and laughing, so, something must be working – could it possibly be the calcium, magnesium, vit D & K I’m taking!!! Of course not I am told. Ha ha, its me who is laughing now, and will continue to with your wonderful help, inspiration and fantastic book full of brilliant information. THANK YOU. Gloria
July 22, 2009
I am 73 and had a prognosis of massive bone loss.My doctor wanted me to take Aclasta, which is a once a year injection. It is also very pricey.I was told to save up for it because if I didnt he wouldnt be responsible for the outcome.I did some research on the net and found that the main ingredient had many side effects.Also
this ingredient was not the same spelling as the one on the net, but
close enough. There was something about it I just didnt trust, plus the doctor making an appointment for me without my permission.
I have scanned your book and find so much validation for my mistrust. I have also started seniors weight training and exercise
regularly now that I have a purpose. I drink unpasteurized milk (moderately) 6000 ml of vitamin D (for my age group)
and make my own kefir, which are said to be superior sources of
calcium. (Dr. Mercola) No wheat products since gluten is not our friend. There is so much to learn from your book and it sure motivated me to trust my own body.
I’m not sure how much we absorb calcium and magnesium in tablet form.I understand that trace minerals might be more important? Forgive me I’m still learning!
Thank you so much, I look
forward to your posts.
Linsea.
August 10, 2009
I am reading your book. It is not the first time that I heard about the low acid diet. It is not always easy to follow. I have an added problem, since I have celiac disease which is probably what caused my osteoporosis in the first place. I do exercise a lot. Thanks for reinforcing my decision not to take drugs.
July 12, 2009
Sounds like new and exciting news. I’m not yet at the point of needing the new drug for advanced ostoprorosis but it’s great to know that there IS something out there that won’t make your life even more miseable. Thanks so much for the update. I will continue my association with your website and appreciate all the helpful information I have gotten from it. Keep up the good work!!
July 8, 2009
Vivian, I have stopped taking Fosamax, and your book awaits my
reading since we have been away on vacation. Have been doing
weight machines for past few years, calcium & Vit. D supplements.
Looking forward to seeing what else in your book.
July 2, 2009
I am sorry that I took osteoporosis medication for about 10 months. I stopped taking the meds cold turkey in April 2009 and I have side-effects that thus far have not gone away. The side effects are stomach and esophagus related and also effects my breathing. Although I have had numerous tests, my lungs are healthy but my stomach and esophasgus are slightly inflamed. Hopefully, this will all go away in the future.
I like the philosophy of trying to remedy problems with one’s body in a more natural way i.e. , diet, exercise, etc. My goal is to stay away from meds if at all possible.
If anyone out there has had similar side effects and gotten over them, please tell me about it.
June 26, 2009
Vivian in early April this year I had a bone scan which showed that I hade Osteopenia and was prescribed Boniva,after I expressed my concern about side effects this was changed to Fosamax,in my research I came upon your web site ordered your book and reviewed all of your e mails and I am convinced that there is another way. I am 84 year old and have many strikes against me,but I think its worth a try,at least I haven’t seen any side effects using your method. By the way I haven’t filled my perscriptions as yet (ha),talk to you at another time. Jimmie
June 25, 2009
Well, Vivian, I hope the second scenario will be in place, but being 77, I will not be here to experience it. My bones will be at rest…
Thank you for being so human, so patient and so generous with your time. Everyday, I watch for your e-mails and I print them in case I would forget your precious advises.
Keep up the good work and as Obama says: God bless you and God bless America!
Therese
St. Lambert, Qc. Canada
June 21, 2009
Really enjoyed your humour in the scenarios – more stress relief!
Am now trying to really understand alkaline and acid foods and get the balance right. Thank you very much for your informative emails.
June 10, 2009
Vivian, I am so thankful I found your web site. I wish I had done my homework before I took the once-a-month Boniva but better late than never!
It has been a little over two months and I am mostly free of the side effects…just some aching in my thighs which comes and goes. I have taken Glucosamine and Chondroiton for several years and take Citracal with D and recently started Citracal plus Genistein which is claimed to increase bone density…also take 200 mg. of magnesium and a super B-complex. My neck and lower back have been bad for many years but Chiropractic has helped and my overall health is good for 78!
Is there any way to get through to Sally Field and ask her to stop recommending Boniva? I see this ad several times a day.
Thanks again for all the info!
Carol Cook
June 9, 2009
Quite a lively imagination you have, Vivian! Fun reading those scenarios. I have been on hormones since 1968 when both ovaries had been removed, a few years apart, because of cysts. Got off them for about 1 1/2 years during the HRT scare, but resumed the pills because I couldn’t sleep at night. My GYN & a Menopause Specialist both want me off Cenestin & on to Boniva. But I refuse, telling them I had rather use natural aids, but they won’t listen – all they know are RXs. I did take another bone density scan, which showed my diet, exercise, increased calcium & vitamin D had improved my osteopina in 2 years time, which they refused to acknowledge! I read every email you send, which I appreciate very much. Please keep up the good work; bless you for sharing your information!
Sincerely,
June 8, 2009
Hi, I like the humorous, and appropriate, names such as Profit & Gamble, Cementex, and Mediscare
The second scenario would be better, although I am also sceptical of many of the claims made by purveyors of herbal remedies and vitamin supplements. There is profiteering at work here too. I believe there was a recent study which showed that large amounts of calcium in the form of supplements, as recommended for post menopausal women, can contribute to heart problems. Seems the best way to improve bone health is through diet and exercise. I would say bone density tests are a waste of time, since they are not only inaccurate, but also do not measure bone strength.
As for “Just Say No to Prescription Drugs,” I’ve been pretty much doing this for the past few years after belatedly discovering how bisphosphonates work and their potential to cause considerable damage. I read “The Myth Of Osteoporosis” by Gillian Sanson which enlightened me about the subject. She seems to say pretty much what you are saying.
May 29, 2009
I loved your scenarios, got a good belly laugh which felt good allover. I’m with Francine and will stick with the grapefruit, or maybe season with a little bit of Portland cement!!! Keep the e-mails coming, I really look forward to your information . Am enjoying reading your book and trying to improve my own bone health.
May 28, 2009
Very interesting scenario!let’s stay with grapefruits!
May 27, 2009
I truly enjoy reading your news letters, it has helped me quite a bit, the use of natural products, rather than Fosomax, Actonal & HRT etc. they are bad news, too many side effects, I would prefer to take the natural products, my health, immune system in general has improved with the correct diet & exercise, thanks to your information. Your research has been like a bible to me. cant thank u enuff.
May 26, 2009
I have been reading the book “The Miracle of Magnesium” by Carolyn Dean MD. Anyone who has osteoporosis should read this book, also share with one’s doctor. I have read similar material and am really sold on the importance of magnesium, especially transdermal magnesium choride oil. Research this on the internet and you will find much information about it.
May 24, 2009
Vivian, I enjoy reading all the articles published. I have been trying to order your book. Could not get my card to go through the computer and called but the recording said leave a name and number and I was not going to be home….so no luck. I have osteopenia. I fractured my back the end of Dec. 08 by picking up something too heavy. I am in a great deal of pain, but am trying to walk, do some exercises and am now going to physical therapy. I also went one time to a reflexologist. I believe she really helped me, but nothing seems to last. I eat healthy. Do you believe in the procedure Vertibroplasty? I went to a specialist in Winston Salem NC and he recommends it. The possible complications don’t look too encouraging. I have to take medication (Tramodol) every day if I plan to do any work outside or in the house. What are your thoughts on the procedure? Am going to try to order the book again this week. Thank you for your help.
May 23, 2009
Dear Vivian, I really appreciate all your eforts to keep us upto date with osteoporosis information. It is a mammoth task no doubt. I look forward to all your emails and the information you impart.
I am however a little confused when I go to the website and I find Q&A’s, blogs etc under different tabs. Reading your responses to others questions really helps answer a lot queries for many but I do find it hard to follow at times.
I am trying very hard to follow your acid/alkaline food suggestions but have fallen off the wagon the last couple of weeks with visitors. I will be back on again soon.
Keep up the good work and Thank you
Gai
May 20, 2009
I really enjoyed the article on Honey and Cinnamon. I will read it more thoroughly later on.
PLEASE, please make it clear to some of your readers that Cementex is Not a drug, and repeat that it was just a product of your imagination.
Kudos to you for all you do!
May 16, 2009
Vivian, thank you for all the info. I found many uses for honey and Cinnamon. The doctor put me on Fosomax for osteoporosis. I took 6 doses and I had many side effects from it. The first week I was on it caused somethin like a ball to come up in my throat, then my breathing was affected, I had major problems with heartburn and stomach problems. I got off, been off 2 weeks and am feeling much better already. I read it would take 4 months to get out of system. I think it may not be that long for me as I only took 6 doses. I am taking tums with calcium, magnesium, 2000 i.u. vitamin D, omega-3 and will take my chances with the osteo. I eat healthy and let your info be a guide for me. Thanks again for all the information. Really a help.
May 14, 2009
I enjoyed your scenarios. You have a good sense of humor. I have picked up a lot of info from all the emails that have been sent to you. Hopefully I will be able to order your book soon. It’s a money problem.
I was on fosomax for 4 1/2 years and lost 4 inches of height. I am now 5′.
After that I was put on forteo for 2 years. I went from osteopenia to osteoporosis then back to osteopenia. Another prescription was ordered but I did not fill it. I am on Osteodenx from Nikken for a year now. The next bone density test is not until spring of 2010. Hope it will show no problems.
I did have a problem with a pinched nerve in my back and the nerves in my left leg. With 2 shots in my back and physical therapy all is back to normal. I am trying to walk more now that my left leg works again. I am 76 and feeling okay with blood pressure meds.
Thanks for printing everyones emails. Sure is a help to me……Carol
May 12, 2009
I just want to thank everyone for the information provided. I am not taking anything in pill form, nor do I want to after the wealth of information shared by everyone and Vivian’s wonderful counsel.
I am taking the Calcium Citrate with Vitamin D, am walking almost daily, and getting some sun as I walk. I also do small weight bearing exercises a few times a week.
I have also altered my diet, and I feel better over all.
Thanks SO much to everyone.
Ellen
May 12, 2009
Hi Vivian; I believe my husband Andre, has osteoporosis, but I’m not so sure, and you will see why when you read this message. Could it be possible he has osteoarthritis?
In 1976, Andre fell fifteen feet to the ground, landed flat on his back and broke just about every bone in his back. He wore a brace for a year before the surgery and had to learn how to walk all over again. A few years later he was supposedly diagnosed with Osteoporosis. I am not a doctor, but I would think that he had osteoporosis only in his spine due to such a severe injury at that time. I don’t think he has it throughout his body, because he has very strong arms and legs. He definitely did shrink though, from 5′ 8″ to approximately 5′4 1/2″ over the years.
On March 30th, Andre tripped on a small stump, which was on a small embankment near our hedge. He broke his left hip and hurt his knee. He was trying to get a branch off the gravel road below. I was working on my computer at the time, as I knew he had gone outside to clean up the lot. After approximately one half hour I realized he hadn’t come back in, so I proceeded downstairs to look out the diningroom window where he said he was picking up pine cones and some branches, but he was nowhere to be found. I also looked out the front door window, but no Andre. I then decided to run upstairs and look out our bedroom window, as you could see everything up there. I saw him lying on the gravel road just below the embankment. I rushed downstairs and out to him. He told me he had been lying there for about half an hour. He also told me he could not move his left leg, and asked me to call an ambulance, which I did, and I followed them to the Cowichan District Hospital in Duncan, B. C. The next afternoon at approximately 1:00 p.m. he had his surgery. They gave him a spinal which numbed him from the waist down. He was totally awake and could hear everything that was going on. They repaired the left hip by putting in a long screw, plate and stitches, which were staples. They gave him oxygen, and apparently his heart beat was irratic, so they gave him cardio pills to regulate his heart beat. After that, they put him on a blood thinner named Coumadin. It prevents blood clots, strokes and heart attacks. Not total prevention, but much less chance of these happening with Coumadin. He was immediately taken off the ASA baby aspirin, which he had been taking for quite a few years, but the doctor said it was not strong enough. They gave him a lot of oxygen after the surgery, as his oxygen levels were quite low the first few days. He also had pneumonia.
I spoke to the surgeon who performed the operation, and he told me that Andre had lost very little blood, and that he had strong hip bones and very strong legs. I was quite surprised, as I thought when Andre fell, it was because of the osteoporosis, and that it would take nothing for him to break a bone. I’m not so sure, as I mentioned earlier, he tripped on a small stump on the embankment and fell hard on the gravel road below.
I spoke to our family physician a few weeks before Andre fell and told him about a natural remedy for Osteoporosis entitled “Osteorganical”, and that I would like him to try it instead of Didrocal, which he had been taking for quite a few years. Our doctor agreed, so I told the nurses at the hospital to make sure he would get the natural Osteorganical, which had been approved by our doctor, and I even went to the Pharmacist with all his other meds to see if Osteorganical would interact with them. She assured me, no. Therefore, Andre has been taking Osteorganical for over a month now.
One thing I don’t understand is that a year ago he had a bone density test, which indicated that he had an increase in bone density in one area of his hip. A year later, we got the results of another bone density test which indicated that his bone density had decreased to something like 3.9, which is borderline. That’s when I decided to look into natural remedies.
Before Andre fell, I bought some two pound weights, which can be used for either the ankles or wrists, at your suggestion. He told me when he went walking, it allowed him to walk a little faster, and that after a few days, the arthritis pain in his hands was just about gone.
Andre was transferred to a rehabilitation centre where he remained for about a week and a half. He was then rushed to emergency, as his oxygen levels were very low, approximately 60? They did not know what was wrong, so they did a gambit of tests and discovered he had double pneumonia, and VRE infection from either the hospital, or healthcare centre. He was in emergency for about three days, and then sent upstairs to an isolation room. He remained there for another three or four days, and is now in an isolation four bed ward. The doctor says there is a definite improvement in his health.
This was quite a setback for him, as now he has to have physio all over again, and needs to build up his strength by eating, and walking. So far, he is unsteady on his feet, as well as shaky sometimes. He’s been through a lot, so I guess it will be some time before he is able to come back home.
Vivian, I know this is a very long-winded e-mail, but I just wanted you to know what Andre has gone through, and I’m hoping the Osteorganical natural remedy will eventually reverse the osteoporosis. Andre is 79 years old. His birthday was April 26th. Do you think it is possible for this reversal to happen one day?
Looking forward to hearing from you at your earliest convenience.
Sincerely,
Margaret Dube
May 11, 2009
Thanks, Vivian, for your book and all your information. I would not take Fosamax and told the Nurse about all the harm it can cause. The Dr. then suggested the nose spray, which you shouldn’t take,if you have any nose bleeds. The suggestion then was the expensive injection yearly, that isn’t covered by insurance,and is deadly to your bones. Was instructied to take D-3,and my reaction was heat. My intire body,especially my feet, was flaming. Worse than any hot flash that I had ever had. Incidentally, I have a reaction to hormones,MSG., and many medications. I am following your reccommendations on exercise,diet, and calcium supplements. My follow-up density test is in 2 years,isn’t covered by insurance any sooner. Thanks again,I am passing along all the critical information, we must edcuate everyone on the affects of Fosamax,etc. Lynda P.S. Did some of your readers really believe cementex is a future medicine? Your story was great!!
October 10, 2009
What type of Vit. D were you taking and how much.
May 5, 2009
Vivian
Someone emailed me and sent me the following article.
What do you think of it?
Honey & Cinnamon
Cinnamon & Honey ~ Bet the drug companies won’t like this one getting around.
Pray that this info will be of some use to you.
Facts on Honey and Cinnamon: It is found that a mixture of honey and cinnamon cures most diseases. Honey is produced in most of the countries of the world. Scientists of today also accept honey as a “Ram Ban” (very effective) medicine for all kinds of diseases. Honey can be used without
any side effects for any kind of diseases.
Today’s science says that even though honey is sweet, if taken in the right dosage as a medicine, it does not harm diabetic patients. Weekly World
News, a magazine in Canada, in its issue dated 17 January, 1995 has given the following list of diseases that can be cured by honey and cinnamon as researched by western scientists:
HEART DISEASES :
Make a paste of honey and cinnamon powder, apply on bread, instead of jelly and jam, and eat it regularly for breakfast. It reduces the cholesterol in the arteries and saves the patient from heart attack. Also those who have already had an attack, if they do this process daily, they are kept mile away from the next attack. Regular use of the above process relieves loss of breath and strengthens the heart beat. In America and Canada, various nursing homes have treated patients successfully and have found that as
you age, the arteries and veins lose their flexibility and get clogged; honey and cinnamon revitalize the arteries and veins.
ARTHRITIS:
Arthritis patients may take daily, morning, and night, one cup of hot water with two spoons of honey and one small teaspoon of cinnamon powder. If taken regularly even chronic arthritis can be cured. In a recent research conducted at the Copenhagen University, it was found that when the doctors
treated their patients with a mixture of one tablespoon Honey and half teaspoon Cinnamon powder before breakfast, they found that within a week, out of the 200 people so treated, practically 73 patients were totally relieved of pain, and within a month, mostly all the patients who could not walk or move around because of arthritis started walking without pain.
BLADDER INFECTIONS:
Take two tablespoons of cinnamon powder and one teaspoon of honey in a glass of lukewarm water and drink it. It destroys the germs in the bladder.
CHOLESTEROL:
Two tablespoons of honey and three teaspoons of Cinnamon Powder mixed in 16 ounces of tea water, given to a cholesterol patient, was found to reduce the level of cholesterol in the blood by 10 percent within two hours. As mentioned for arthritic patients, if taken three times a day, any chronic cholesterol is cured. According to information received in the said journal, pure honey taken with food daily relieves complaints of cholesterol.
COLDS: Those suffering from common or severe colds should take one tablespoon lukewarm honey with 1/4 spoon cinnamon powder daily for three days. This process will cure most chronic cough, cold, and clear the sinuses.
UPSET STOMACH:
Honey taken with cinnamon powder cures stomach ache and also clears stomach ulcers from the root.
GAS:
According to the studies done in India and Japan, it is revealed that if honey is taken with cinnamon powder the stomach is relieved of gas.
IMMUNE SYSTEM:
Daily use of honey and cinnamon powder strengthens the immune system and protects the body from bacteria and viral attacks. Scientists have found that honey has various vitamins and iron in large amounts. Constant use of honey strengthens the white blood corpuscles to fight bacteria and viral
diseases.
INDIGESTION:
Cinnamon powder sprinkled on two tablespoons of honey taken before food relieves acidity and digests the heaviest of meals.
INFLUENZA:
A scientist in Spain has proved that honey contains a natural ‘ Ingredient’
which kills the influenza germs and saves the patient from flu.
LONGEVITY:
Tea made with honey and cinnamon powder, when taken regularly, arrests the ravages of old age. Take four spoons of honey, one spoon of cinnamon powder and three cups of water and boil to make like tea. Drink 1/4 cup, three to four times a day. It keeps the skin fresh and soft and arrests old age. Life spans also increases and even a 100 year old, starts performing the chores of a 20-year-old.
PIMPLES:
Three tablespoons of honey and one teaspoon of cinnamon powder paste. Apply this paste on the pimples before sleeping and wash it next morning with warm water. If done daily for two weeks, it removes pimples from the root.
SKIN INFECTIONS:
Applying honey and cinnamon powder in equal parts on the affected parts cures eczema, ringworm and all types of skin infections.
WEIGHT LOSS:
Daily in the morning one half hour before breakfast on an empty stomach and at night before sleeping, drink honey and cinnamon powder boiled in one cup of water. If taken regularly, it reduces the weight of even the most obese person. Also, drinking this mixture regularly does not allow the fat to accumulate in the body even though the person may eat a high calorie diet.
CANCER:
Recent research in Japan and Australia has revealed that advanced cancer of the stomach and bones have been cured successfully. Patients suffering from these kinds of cancer should daily take one tablespoon of honey with one teaspoon of cinnamon powder for one month three time s a day.
FATIGUE:
Recent studies have shown that the sugar content of honey is more helpful rather than being detrimental to the strength of the body. Senior citizens, who take honey and cinnamon powder in equal parts, are more alert and flexible. Dr. Milton, who has done research, says that a half tablespoon of honey taken in a glass of water and sprinkled with cinnamon powder, taken daily after brushing and in the afternoon at about 3:00 P.M.
when the vitality of the body starts to decrease, increases the vitality of
the body within a week.
BAD BREATH:
People of South America, first thing in the morning, gargle with one teaspoon of honey and cinnamon powder mixed in hot water, so their breath
stays fresh throughout t he day.
HEARING LOSS:
Daily morning and night honey and cinnamon powder, taken in equal parts
restore hearing. Remember when we were kids? We had toast with real butter and cinnamon sprinkled on it!
You might want to share this information with a friend, kinfolks and love d ones ~ everyone
needs healthy help information ~ what they do with it is up to them ~ share with your
email buddies !!!!! Cheers, have a nice day.Just remember how industrious Bees are. NB: this is the latest BUZZ.— Reuters!!
——-Subject: Fw: Honey & cinnamon – very important info
Honey & Cinnamon
Cinnamon & Honey ~ Bet the drug companies won’t like this one getting around.
Pray that this info will be of some use to you.
Facts on Honey and Cinnamon: It is found that a mixture of honey and
cinnamon cures most diseases. Honey is produced in most of the countries
of the world. Scientists of today also accept honey as a “Ram Ban” (very
effective) medicine for all kinds of diseases. Honey can be used without
any side effects for any kind of diseases.
Today’s science says that even though honey is sweet, if taken in the right
dosage as a medicine, it does not harm diabetic patients. Weekly World
News, a magazine in Canada, in its issue dated 17 January, 1995 has given
the following list of diseases that can be cured by honey and cinnamon as
researched by western scientists:
HEART DISEASES :
Make a paste of honey and cinnamon powder, apply on bread, instead of
jelly and jam, and eat it regularly for breakfast. It reduces the cholesterol
in the arteries and saves the patient from heart attack. Also those who have
already had an attack, if they do this process daily, they are kept miles
away from the next attack. Regular use of the above process relieves loss
of breath and strengthens the heart beat. In America and Canada, various
nursing homes have treated patients successfully and have found that as
you age, the arteries and veins lose their flexibility and get clogged; honey
and cinnamon revitalize the arteries and veins.
ARTHRITIS:
Arthritis patients may take daily, morning, and night, one cup of hot water
with two spoons of honey and one small teaspoon of cinnamon powder. If
taken regularly even chronic arthritis can be cured. In a recent research
conducted at the Copenhagen University, it was found that when the doctors
treated their patients with a mixture of one tablespoon Honey and half
teaspoon Cinnamon powder before breakfast, they found that within a week,
out of the 200 people so treated, practically 73 patients were totally
relieved of pain, and within a month, mostly all the patients who could not
walk or move around because of arthritis started walking without pain.
BLADDER INFECTIONS:
Take two tablespoons of cinnamon powder and one teaspoon of honey in a
glass of lukewarm water and drink it. It destroys the germs in the bladder.
CHOLESTEROL:
Two tablespoons of honey and three teaspoons of Cinnamon Powder mixed in
16 ounces of tea water, given to a cholesterol patient, was found to reduce
the level of cholesterol in the blood by 10 percent within two hours. As
mentioned for arthritic patients, if taken three times a day, any chronic
cholesterol is cured. According to information received in the said
journal, pure honey taken with food daily relieves complaints of cholesterol.
COLDS:
Those suffering from common or severe colds should take one tablespoon
lukewarm honey with 1/4 spoon cinnamon powder daily for three days. This
process will cure most chronic cough, cold, and clear the sinuses.
UPSET STOMACH:
Honey taken with cinnamon powder cures stomach ache and also clears
stomach ulcers from the root.
GAS:
According to the studies done in India and Japan, it is revealed that if
honey is taken with cinnamon powder the stomach is relieved of gas.
IMMUNE SYSTEM:
Daily use of honey and cinnamon powder strengthens the immune system and
protects the body from bacteria and viral attacks. Scientists have found
that honey has various vitamins and iron in large amounts. Constant use of
honey strengthens the white blood corpuscles to fight bacteria and viral
diseases.
INDIGESTION:
Cinnamon powder sprinkled on two tablespoons of honey taken before food
relieves acidity and digests the heaviest of meals.
INFLUENZA:
A scientist in Spain has proved that honey contains a natural ‘ Ingredient’
which kills the influenza germs and saves the patient from flu.
LONGEVITY:
Tea made with honey and cinnamon powder, when taken regularly, arrests the
ravages of old age. Take four spoons of honey, one spoon of cinnamon powder
and three cups of water and boil to make like tea. Drink 1/4 cup, three to
four times a day. It keeps the skin fresh and soft and arrests old age.
Life spans also increases and even a 100 year old, starts performing the
chores of a 20-year-old.
PIMPLES:
Three tablespoons of honey and one teaspoon of cinnamon powder paste.
Apply this paste on the pimples before sleeping and wash it next morning with
warm water. If done daily for two weeks, it removes pimples from the root.
SKIN INFECTIONS:
Applying honey and cinnamon powder in equal parts on the affected parts
cures eczema, ringworm and all types of skin infections.
WEIGHT LOSS:
Daily in the morning one half hour before breakfast on an empty stomach
and at night before sleeping, drink honey and cinnamon powder boiled in one
cup of water. If taken regularly, it reduces the weight of even the most
obese person. Also, drinking this mixture regularly does not allow the fat
to accumulate in the body even though the person may eat a high calorie diet.
CANCER:
Recent research in Japan and Australia has revealed that advanced cancer of
the stomach and bones have been cured successfully. Patients suffering from
these kinds of cancer should daily take one tablespoon of honey with one
teaspoon of cinnamon powder for one month three time s a day.
FATIGUE:
Recent studies have shown that the sugar content of honey is more helpful
rather than being detrimental to the strength of the body. Senior citizens,
who take honey and cinnamon powder in equal parts, are more
alert and flexible. Dr. Milton, who has done research, says that a half
tablespoon of honey taken in a glass of water and sprinkled with cinnamon
powder, taken daily after brushing and in the afternoon at about 3:00 P.M.
when the vitality of the body starts to decrease, increases the vitality of
the body within a week.
BAD BREATH:
People of South America, first thing in the morning, gargle with one
teaspoon of honey and cinnamon powder mixed in hot water, so their breath
stays fresh throughout t he day.
HEARING LOSS:
Daily morning and night honey and cinnamon powder, taken in equal parts
restore hearing. Remember when we were kids? We had toast with real butter and cinnamon sprinkled on it!
You might want to share this information with a friend, kinfolks and love d ones ~ everyone
needs healthy help information ~ what they do with it is up to them ~ share with your
email buddies !!!!! Cheers, have a nice day.Just remember how industrious Bees are. NB: this is the latest BUZZ.— Reuters!!
August 20, 2009
Hi Vivian,
Even though I have never met you , I feel like I know you! Thanks so much for all the info . I was diagnosed with Osteoporosis and I was given the prescription but never filled it. I truly believe in taking care of the issues of our bodies the natural way. When I think back over the history of my life -everything that has ever been wrong with me I can trace it back to too much acid . I am saving for your book . I know it will be well worth the cost. The info on honey and cinnamon is great.
I do have one question- everytime I take any form of calcium (even from the health food store) my bones, especially my wrists begin to hurt (they feel like they are broken) If I stop taking the calcium it stops hurting.
thanks so much , I appreciate all you do.
Sue Sienkiewicz
May 4, 2009
Vivian
I have emailed you a couple of times but I do not know whether you have received them. So I am still trying to make contact with you.
Thanks for these helpful tips.
I have a question: Sometimes you hear about people who have Osteoporosis shrinking in size or becoming rather stooped. Is this true? Is this just a fairy tale? Maybe becoming stooped isn’t caused from Osteoporosis. It may be just deterioration of the vertebra or another disease.
I try to walk and sit with my head up and shoulders back.
What is you response, Vivian. I will be waiting to hear.
Vivian I would like you to write about grape fruit as a fruit that helps to strengthen bones or to help bone growth.
Hope to hear from you soon
Maureen
April 28, 2009
Dear Vivian,
Thank you so much for all your informative emails. There is lots of useful information. I preferred your second scenario.
Unfortunately, I too accepted the doctor’s advice and reluctantly had an infusion of Aclasta last summer, since Fosamax and Bonviva had caused such problems with reflux. I bitterly regret it as I have suffered since then with constant problems with my teeth and gums and am really fearful for the health of my jaw. I have also suffered a broken ankle since having the infusion!
It was good to find your website which confirmed my doubts about the drugs.I am determined never to take bisphosphonates again and am trying to follow your dietary and exercise advice.
Thanks again.Keep up the good work.
Rosemary Devon England
April 25, 2009
VIVIAN,
LOVE YOUR EMAILS,I HAVE GAIN MUCH INFO.FROM THEM.I AM ONE OF THOSE PEOPLE WHO REFUSES MEDS FOR MY BONES.SO MY DR.ORDERED1-PILL- 50,000 MG,OF VIT D PER MONTH,TO ME IT SOUND LIKE A LOT TO TAKE AT ONE TIME.SO I STARTED TAKING 1400 MG ADAY,TO COMPENSATE.WITH MY CALCIUM,VIT 150 B+ ,MAG,POS.
I HAVE A TORN M.IN MY KNEE THEY WANT TO DO SURGERY,BUT I AM HOLDING OFF,THE PAIN IS GREAT ,I REFUSE PAIN PILLS,
I AM ON B/P PILLS/TYROID,I WISH I COULD GET OFF THEM ALSO.I AM 72 IN MAY AND TRYING TO STAY IN REASONABLLY GOOD HEALTH ,SO I CAN HELP OTHERS.
KEEP YOUR GOOD WORK UP.
GOD BLESS YOU
MERLYN S
April 23, 2009
I enjoyed your article, sorry I am unable to comment on it at this time, due to a time factor. I will be looking forward to you next bulletin/article.
Thank you and keep up the good work.
April 18, 2009
Hello Vivian
)
I read with great interest your two scenarios, if only dreams would come true then we could ALL live in a carefree, pain free world without the use of any type of drugs what-so-ever and have a natural healthier living….if only.
I can see a MASSIVE MULTI MILLION DOLLAR LAWSUIT, suing the company who made these drugs on TNN news, looming.
I have NEVER been put under pressure from either my Rheumatology Consultant or regular G.P to take the Bisphosphonate drugs to strengthen my bones. The fact is that after the Dexa Scan, I was diagnosed with a “T” score of −2.5, as are millions of other men and women, and told, as I am on the “THRESHOLD” of Osteoporosis we would recommend that you take this drug to help your well being and provide you make stronger bones.
No one ever told me that I was actually destroying them and that they would die. A male patient went in to see my dental Consultant last week just before I did, and the doctor had to break the news to him that half his jaw bone is dead, all because he took Bisphosphonates. I do not want that happening to me which is why I have stopped this drug. I don’t know how much damaged that I have done in the 3 years that I taken them and pray that damage is minimal.
I like reading all that you send out to me in your e mails and I greatly appreciate all of the work that you do to help all of us who suffer in this way, thank you so much, long may you continue to do so.
best wishes
Marysia
April 15, 2009
Hi Vivian,
Thank you so much for all your email. I too, print it out so I have it handy for consult. I do have your book which I keep for reference. Working to keep my Ph balance in keel & do walking. I do not excerise because of aggravating my L knee &L shoulder repair gardening. I also have a sliding rib & just had a shot in it as that pain is no. 6 on a scale. Nothing seems to help it. Any suggestions I would appreciate. I stick with the diet as much as possible & guess what I lost 5 pounds. Imagine. That is good.
L loved the two scenarios and at 77 hope I am not around in twennty years. Thank you again for all your expertise on this subject. Joan Miller
April 11, 2009
Vivian—those having the dexascans should verify that the machines are current in their callibration and certified by governing medical examiners. It is also very important to have the same machine used on any follow-ups to insure diagnostic continuity. There are slight to marked variations between machine brands.
March 30, 2009
Vivian,
I am impressed by your work. Your book confirms what my naturopath advocates and I am proceeding to adopt the foods which contribute to bone building.
At 63 and with 6 fractured vertebrae plus a verteboplasty operation on one vertebra, I was in a stste of shock. I too readily accepted the doctor’s advice and had an infusion of Aclasta (detergent based!)subsequent visits to the specialist confirm their dedication to drugs and they all seem to have a total disregard for alternative therapies. I think it’s because they see it as a disease and not an imbalance which is capable of being healed by the body itself, providing the correct regime is followed.
I a glad to have your reassurance to supplement what I have come to believe.
Thank you
Ted
Melbourne Australia
March 30, 2009
Thanks Vivian for these two wonderful examples of choices we have for the future. It’s great to see alternative information in such an entertaining way. Do you know of Nancy Appleton’s work? Similar information.
Thanks again.
March 26, 2009
Why do I get the impression, from some of the early posts above, that some people actually BELIEVE that the first scenario is TRUE? Did they not get the joke in the name “Dee Seat”, or “Profit & Gamble”? That’s hysterical, and VERY WELL DONE. But to not see “Ms. Seat also confirmed that Cementex is covered by Mediscare” as a huge joke? They must have been looking for a better drug, and Cementex really sounded GOOD!
Apparently people see what they want to see, and completely overlooked your statement that “One is where the ‘cure’ of osteoporosis and osteopenia revolves around prescription drugs, similar to nowadays”. Perhaps it would have helped to say “The first one” instead, although I doubt it. I guess I got it clearly because my Grandmother was a London Cockney, which is why many people don’t get MY sense of humor. The entries of those who “believed” were almost as funny (if they weren’t tragic) as was your Breaking News! I really enjoyed your News! Keep it up! But next time, you may have to somewhere include that it’s all a joke. Too bad.
Jafra
March 21, 2009
Vivian, Thanks so much for all of your e-mails. I have not completely read al of your book as yet, but have gone through each chapter. I also have changed my Calcium tablets to Citracal + with D and Bone Builder. I like it so much better. Much easier on my stomach. I have been taking a Osteo-Fit class three times a week since Nov.
It includes 25 minutes of Cardio (treadmill) and 25 minutes of weight baring machines twice a week and the other day is 50 minutes of floor exercises with mostly weights and stability ball. I love the class and will continue. I have also stopped taking Fosamax and will have my Bone Density taken again the first of April. My T score for my spine is -3.1 and the hip is normal. I am 71 years young. Please keep up the good work.
March 21, 2009
Dear Vivian,
Your website was the first intimation I had that Osteoporosis could be reversed. I have since read other books that say the same thing – Hallejulah. I most definitely did not want to take the Actonel Combi my doctor prescribed for me (I still have the prescription unfilled). When I asked her about the side effects she said “I would not live long enough to be troubled by them” !!!!! I don’t believe her.
So I have started on the vitamins, diet and exercise and have peace of mind again now that I have decided not, ever, to take any of those drugs.
It is wonderful to read all the letters from everyone – what a wonderful way to be able to help each other with various hints and suggestions.
Last December (08) all my muscles, from neck to ankle seized up overnight. I could barely move. At the moment I am taking 1/4 of 25mg prednisolone daily – to keep me mobile. I am not sure if I have fibromyalgia or polymyalgia rheumatica (am to see specialist in about a week). Does anyone have any ideas on how to unspasm my muscles ?
So thank you for all your good research Vivian. Your work has obviously given hope to alot of women. I look forward to your next newsletter. Val 2
March 19, 2009
Just a quick note to say that strontium supplementation is being used by a lot of docs now. they are prescribing doses of 250, 500, 600 mg. The latest i heard is that SIX milligrams of strontium are safe.
March 16, 2009
I have taken Calcium, Vitamin D, Glucosamine/Chondroiton, Senior Vitamins, etc. for years, and have been taking the generic for Foxamax for several months. You’d think my bones would be healthy. Last January (2208) I had a fracture in my right ankle area…..finally that healed. This January I was having (and am still having) pain in my groin area. After going to my gyn Dr. and my Internist, I ended up going to an orthopedic dr. Guess what? I have a non displaced bone fractue in the pelvic area. I wonder what’s next!I also (according to a bone density test and X rays) have osteopenia.
March 15, 2009
Hi Vivian!
I have a problem with my PTH and my endocrinologist want me to take Fosamax. Of course, he told me that I have osteoporosis but, do I have to suppose that every one who suffer that problem have a PTH too high or is it a particuliar problem for me only?
I went to see a naturopath who puts me on a treatment. Since the time I started in september 2007 my PTH get lower around 9.7 (it was at 12.4 at the beginning) I want to continue with that treatment and follow your recommandation in your book because I don’t want to go to see him again (endocrinologist)…
I thint I made a good decision
Jeanne M. from Mtl. QC. Canada
March 14, 2009
Have received your book – sat down and read it in one go. I will now read it more slowly and digest the contents. Saw my Doctor and informed him I no longer required perscription drugs due to side effects. He immediately told me to drink lots of milk and I told him your comments. He blushed! I mentioned about hard bones compared to thinner and more flexible and agreed that point. He said I could not have another scan, but my hospital said 18 months ago when this was diagnosed that I could have one in three year – 18 months time. I am taking Calcium 1200 mg as calcium phosphate, Vitamin D3 800 I.U. as powder for oral suspension. The Doctor gives me this on the NHS. I purchase Mangesium after reading your book 300 mg and take it with the others. I also now only take half the dose at a time i.e. lunchtime and evening meal. To be honest I did now have any tummy upsets on the full dose. Also I did not get any side effects from using Protelos but did not like what I read. I will have to wait 18 months to see the results. I have bought wrist weights 1 kilo gram. and doing housework and cleaning windows takes on a whole new meaning. I actually enjoy doing these as I know I am benefiting. I do aerobics once a week – 50 mins and 30 mins in jym. I dance once or twice most weeks and walk whenever possible but I have to watch my knees as I have wear and tear due to walking 10 miles twice a week on the moor, but it was worth it. I saw parts of Devon I would never have seen otherwise. I am 70 years of age so I expect some places to get worn. I still feel in my 50’s in my mind, but get beaten every Monday by a group of ladies in their late 80’s and 90’s at scrabble. I am putting a notice on the board at jym regarding your web site for any ladies with similar complaints. Thank you for your advice and e-mails also the ladies who contribute. It is nice to know others are trying to combat this complaint with commonsense and perseverance. Good Luck and Good Health to everyone. Keep smiling and be positive.
Patricia Bates – Devon, England.
March 11, 2009
Vivian, I like your second scenario, however would like to suggest an even better one; that we eventually come home to our true balance with our beautiful planet. Our compromised health is a symptom of our broken covenant with the laws of nature. Until we begin to place value on our integrity with these laws, some of which are cooperation and compassion, we will continue to have these symptoms showing up in our bones; the foundation for our bodies that house our spirits while we are attending this ’school’. Vitamins, whole foods and therapeutic modalities are good adjuncts for the transition, but can be another version of the concept the drug companies embody – to put a bandage on the symptoms but circumvent the real issue. I encourage everyone who takes this high road for healing to discover the message our bodies are really saying to us and to search for where we have lost our connection to our hearts, communities, country and the planet. It starts with the breath, and finally to walk our talk of truth, love and compassion. I honor the truth that Ruth offered about finding the middle path to create a bridge of communication between opposing forces, to unite with a common goal to begin cooperating and building a strong foundation in our healthcare community that embraces truth rather than economy. Perhaps the extreme out of balance nature of our current world health has been the necessary impetus to be the agent of change for balance and finally, blessings to all the people who have had to experience the hard lessons of dis ease to bring us to this point in time.
- Lesley
March 9, 2009
Hi there, thanks for the update, Viv. I don’t expect to put my body thru any more punishment as what i experienced with Reclast, thinking I was going to die for 15 hours, then the symptoms lasting from Dec. 12 to a couple of weeks ago. I’ve written to Medicare, AARP, the doctors and said I’m NOT going to pay the $350.00 charges! I wrote Reclast, and got some person from India whom I could not understand clearly saying:’they are not responsible, call my doctor!” I retorted with: “Yes, you ARE, you are killing people with your poison, the lab test animals died, and you ARE responsible!” I also told him I am going to take this further, sending the info to congress.
Now you’re probably not going to bother with me again, but i am a fighter and will do as I have stated. The FDA sucks! – Roz
March 9, 2009
Vivian, please tell Talei to try hyaluronic acid for her knees. I was told that I had osteoarthritis in my knees and if the pain got too bad I should have cortisone or hyaluronic acid compound shots. I bought hyaluronic acid from my favorite supplement site and the pain was gone within 10 days. The swelling also disappeared. I told my brother who had a similar problem, and it worked for him, too. Please try this before surgery and see if it works. I walk every day for 2 miles, pain free. I am 67 and working on the alkalinity of my diet. Will be awhile before another bone density test to see the results. No broken bones!
Linda
March 7, 2009
Hi Vivian – I have just finished reading your two scenarios, and I trust that the second one is what really happens. In fact, I believe it is beginning now if enough people start questioning the meds they are prescribed. I feel extremely fortunate to have found your web site after ingesting 1 of the monthly Actonel, which left me feeling horrible all over. I certainly am thankful for your research, and I even took my book with me to my last doctor visit. Thank goodness my family practice doctor is totally supportive and trying to help me with the natural approach. The gyn was the one that prescribed the Actonel and tried to scare me that I should be careful not to fall. I have been taking the MCHC calcium and reading one of the comments perhaps that isn’t the best. I use to take the calcium citrate as I had been told that absorbs better. I had already made so many adjustments in my diet after open heart surgery two years ago, that it just took a little refining to follow your suggestions. The biggest thing was giving up milk. I have been using soy now and have less stomach aches. My doctor does think I may not be digesting my food properly and gave me a natural supplement Zypan. She didn’t think I had enough acid, so now I am a bit concerned since we are to have an alkaline balance. Thanks for your e-mails. I am always eager to read them.
February 25, 2009
Hi Vivian:
Receive all your e-mails and love the information you share. I am following your advice…..no meds….primarily veggies, fruit, soy milk, calcium citrate w/magnesium and vitamin D supplements. I have been exercising, however, due to unexpected emergency hernia surgery, I have been curtailed a bit.
All you send is sincerely appreciated. Stay well.
Marilyn
February 24, 2009
Good Afternoon –
That’s an interesting senario. At 72, I’m not libel to see the outcome, however – I’ll fill you in on whats happening right now with me.
Since I recieved your book two months ago, I started following the directions as best I can. It required a whole new life style change which includes eating the right foods regularly. and exercise every day. I’m following the exercise pattern from the book “Pain Free” by Peter Ecoscue and it’s not hard to do but very effective.
Frankly, Vivian, I feel great now and I’m looking forward to gardening and camping (if it ever quits snowing)
Oddly enough, my Dr. is going along with me on this and says we’ll do another density scan in 9 months to a year to see what the change is. He considers me some kind of an experiment because I’m such a disappointment as a patient.
Please keep up the good work – I think you may have saved my scrawny backside.
Gerry Hilton
Calgary, Alberta
February 23, 2009
Dear Vivian,
It would be helpful to hear your response to some of these comments. I have 3 freind who, like me, get very constipated from calcium, all brands including calcium citrate and the powder. I eat yogurt and try to follow your diet and eat tons of greens. Do you have any other suggestions on how to get the calcium in?
My spine bone density is improved and the hip is still osteoporosis but I am stepping up the exercise to 5 days @ 30 min on the treadmill. Thank you Donna R
February 23, 2009
Hi Vivian
Thank you so much for sending me all the information about bone health. I was on Actonel for 10 months and regret taking my doctor’s advice on trying it. My ankles swelled, terrible heartburn, chest pain, stomach pain, etc. I told my doctor I quit taking prescription drugs for osteoporosis. Now I am on prescription medication for heartburn. Also, I am going for exrays on my esophagus because of the heartburn.
I plan to order your book on bone health soon. Meanwhile, continue sending all your information.
February 21, 2009
Keep up the great info! The drugs are so ridiculous, if all those drug manufacturers were as smart as they think they are they would figure out the truth!
February 20, 2009
Hi Vivian: I really appreciate receiving the newsletters…thanks for keeping us up to date on the latest research. My doctor didn’t fight my decision not to take Fosamax, but it seems like every other physician I’ve spoken to about this since (I work for an integrated health system) thinks it’s really crazy that I won’t take it. When I ask them if they’ve read the research on bisphosphonates and what they do to bones, I get a blank stare. This confirms to me that physicians are indeed brainwashed to sell whatever the pharmaceutical reps convince them to prescribe for various conditions. Too often, the cure is worse than the disease if you rely on drugs to help you. I am 58 and am totally committed to advocating for myself and doing everything I can to take care of my body with exercise, supplements and healthy foods. Thank you for helping me do that.
February 16, 2009
I’ve been reading that eating animal products raises the body’s acid load and that this contributes to leaching calcium from the bones. I’ve been a vegan for about a year, and I take calcium citrate. I walk two miles or more a day and my weight is normal. I was diagnosed with osteoporosis a few years ago, and took Fosamax and then Boniva, until I read about the dangers of both, and then stopped the drugs. Do you recommend a plant-based diet? I’m concerned about how to get enough protein without getting too many calories.
February 16, 2009
Hi Vivian
I loved your latest email. Please keep me on your mailing list.
I have been taking calcium lactate on the advice of a natural healer. What is your opinion of this supplement?
Your loyal reader,
Sharon
February 13, 2009
thank you vivian for your emais; i was not ignoring you by not replying to your emails and with regrdyour book, i can’t afford it….
i liked your senarios too; anything is possible! p.s. i have stoped taking the Evista perscription, then i informed my doctor and he perscribed me now with Calcichew-D3 Forte tablets; will these cure the fructure i already have for a long time now. i have fallen hard on my bottom and felt pain going through all the way to my back and spine. do you have any comments on this? i truly appreciate your support. i had a hesterectemyat the young age of 26, now i’m paying furher with my health from depression to osteoperosis to stressing about the future as these issues deteriorate.
best regards
ruth
February 8, 2009
I have purchased your book. Lots of good information and have passed your website along to others.
Keep it coming.
Denis M
February 7, 2009
I am very glad and privileged to have read your book( I still go over every now and then). I am trying to follow the food guide and have also encourage my family to do so plus walking exercise. Aside from your food guide, I still take calcium vitamins and calcium supplement calcium aspartate anhydrous. Hopefully by the time I see my doctor my bone density have increased and hope to be pain free soon.
Thank you again for the information and your hard work of research.
More power to you always and God bless!
Vangie Knowles
February 4, 2009
Hi Vivian
Thanks for all your hard work and research. Two great scenarios I stopped taking medication in November after 3 months I was not happy on it and it did not like me too many side effects. I am determined to help the Osteoporosis with supplements diet and weight bearing exercises which I do 3 times a week.
I am spreading the word here in England to as many people I know even a friend who has chronic Arthritis is looking at the diet I live in the lovely county of Cheshire it’s good to share views and ideas with so many other poeple
Thanks Vivian
Pamela
February 2, 2009
I am a 63-year-old with osteopenia in the hip diagnosed about 5 years ago. I have been back and forth taking and not taking Fosamax. I had been taking Strontium (citrate) 227 mg daily for awhile. The Strontium gave me diahrrea. Now that I am off both of them for about 3 months, my hip stopped hurting and the muscle/joint aches are gone. I excercise 3-5 times a week in classes from Pelottis to low-impact aerobics.The exercise is so valuable for my mood and flexibility. (I am still working and will do so full-time for at least 5 more years). I take calcium-magnesium and Vitamin D. I have abundant energy and feel that I live at a level of consciousness that I will not fall. I have almost perfect blood pressure.
Your emails have helped to make me clear that I will obey my naturopath who has researched the supplements I am taking (He also recommended Strontium.) and that includes staying away from Fosamax. I confess that I bypassed some of your emails and missed the acid info re: the diet. I eat very well – lots of fruits and veggies and often organic – but I love my desserts. I drink no soda and am mostly caffeine free. I drink pi water, which is filtered and has great health value.
And I am also confused as to what you are recommending to maintain health bone structure. Are you pointing to a particular supplement. Also, I am not convinced of the value of getting the book. But I am so grateful for your research and concern. Thank you and if it is possible to resend me the acid-free diet info, I would be most grateful.
January 29, 2009
Very interested in your scenario. You certainly know what you are talking about. I, too, refuse to take any of the medication out there to prevent osteporosis. I do have osteopenia and have been taking calcium, magnesium and vitamin D. I eat well, exercise and am very youthful for my age – 77 years. I do, however, have Scoliosis and I wish there was something I could do to improve my appearance. I am very fortunate that I do not have any pain and attribute this to the fact that I eat well and exercise. If there is anyone out there who is also affected by this I would appreciate their input. I love your book and your e-mails. Keep them coming.
January 28, 2009
I have recently bought and read your book and found it very interesting.
Some years ago I studied the effects of Acid/Alkaline foods simply because of an upset stomach and was unaware of it’s effect on bones. So now knowing it has a two fold effect makes it my kind of diet.
A few months ago I broke my shoulder and was told to get a bone density test
which I haven’t yet got around to. I take calcium [as carbonate vit D3 magnesium zinc copper manganese] I have arthritis but do not take prescription drugs. They’re too upsetting to the system.
I shall re-read your book to properly absorb its contents
Thank-you for your intersting comments
January 25, 2009
Very interesting scenario. I’m determined to forget about these “new” drugs for osteo…. – will continue with calcium, D, and mag. – and I refuse to be a hand at the drug companies getting rich and using us for guinea pigs. I know my doctors are very unhappy with me, but it’s my body. I’m told I’m a “young” 77, so I must be doing something right.
Thanks for your info and input.
January 24, 2009
Regarding your 4th October 2008 scenarios for the future …..
Your scenarios are beautifully expressive, as is everything else you write. And your research into osteoporisis has been incredible – thank you from the bottom of my heart. BUT, scenarios like these are so overblown that you devalue your central message.
Once in a while it’s great to have a laugh. But those types of conspiracy-level comments crop up so very often in your writing.
Yes, I do believe that big pharma is out to make mega-money without any regard for consumer’s health; and that governments and FDA approvals have been manipulated and abused by lobbyists and corporations (as have so many processes that affect all spheres of our lives). So your bravery in pointing this out, and providing us with well-researched, accurate, wholistic information is an incredible gift to all of us.
However, I also know of certified organic businesses that are just as money-grabbing and cynical as big pharma (albeit on a smaller budget, and with minimal influence on government). And I know of one or two ordinary conservative businesses that genuinely care and operate with integrity and humanity. And of many many businesses that, if they only knew what was going on behind the scenes, would be prepared to behave more ethically.
The black-and-white extreme scenarios you incessantly feed us are only making you look one-sided. Taking sides implies schisms, and schisms don’t help in the long run.
You are such an effective communicator. You are a wonder in how you get across the dangers of believing every word the health care industry feeds us. Surely you can manage this without resorting to repetitive, simplistic, extreme, black-and-white conspiracy scenarios. Please, please, don’t devalue your spectacularly wonderful message.
For similar work to yours (in a different health area), have a look at how Petrea King expresses herself. She is just as damning of the “system” as you. But after several years she is now getting doctors and heath authorities to not only hear her views, but to slowly start adopting them too.
Your message is so vital – but to be truely effective, it needs to get beyond us individual subscribers. It needs to eventually filter through to doctors, to health policy decision makers, to the people who are in a position to change the “system” and improve it for millions of people around the world.
Please, please, don’t put doctors off side by categorising them all as monsters or idiots or bribe-taking-pawns of big pharma. Please, don’t create a schism where alternative medicine is perfect and Western medicine is evil. Both sides have faults. Both sides have valuable input. If only we can get some cooperation between them instead of deepening the already-existing war between them. By opting for a simplistic good-guy-bad-guy approach, you’ll just perpetuate that war – you will affront the very people we need to effect lasting deep-seated change – the people who can take your fabulous research to the whole world.
You are so good at communicating Vivian. And your message is vital. It is worthy of being adopted right now by us subscribers, and also of being adopted longterm by mainstream policymakers so it can be carried to the world.
Please honour the value in your message by altering your communication approach. Please keep the long-term in view too.
Ruth
January 24, 2009
I have been receiving your e-mails now for about a month. My internist wanted me to take Actonal – she gave me some samples and a prescription. Never took them after reading stuff on the internet. I have osteopenia according to my test – my femoral bone density was -2.3. I have increased my calcium intake but that is all so far. I use to walk 2 miles every morning but can’t since Nov. because I now have plantar faciitis. Have a podorthist at a good shoe store helping me and I do exercises for it. I also had a 62 RA factor on a blood test and am waiting to see a rheumatologist on Feb. 3. I want to see what he thinks of all my problems and does more blood tests. Most days every joint in my body hurts. I also want him to do blood tests to see what my calcium and Vitamin D levels are. I take Zocor for high cholesterol and sometimes suspect that contributes to my aches. I also take coumadin because I have a fib. I have taken that for 3 years now and suspect it has caused the osteopenia. I also have colitis and take asacol. All these drugs are probably causing my aches and pains and osteo but what is one to do? I will let you know what the rheumatologist has to say.
Thanks for all your e-mails.
Dorothy
January 22, 2009
I like the 2nd scenario best. I am a believer that drugs don’t get to the root of the problem and end up creating other problems and you end up with more drugs to alleviate the problem the drug created.
I am looking forward to the day when a patient can choose their method of treatment and the doctor they wish to go to. I am appalled to see the Insurance companies telling my doctor which medicine I should take because they are trying to save money. Also, why have drug insurance plans when now they only cover certain medications and if you want a brand name you have to pay the bigger postion of the cost.
I sometimes feel like they want us to be sick so they can get more money in their packets.
It is my desire that people will wake up and start taking their health into their own hands by researching the best method of treatment for their condition.
January 21, 2009
I was told I had osteoporosis and that Reclast would not help. but was given Forteo. I tried the drug, but had bad side effects. Than they wanted me to try Actanol and I refused as I have reflux have all I can do to keep that under control. Finally I just told my Dr. I wanted to go the old fashion way with trying a new calciumn supplement (Citrecal with genistein and boron. I have started a low impact weight program and walk as often as I can. I will have another scan in May 2009 to see if I am stable or still losing density. I also take 1000 mg of vit. d-3 Am I on the right track? Any other action should I be considering? Thanks for your many e-mails.
January 15, 2009
Hi Vivian,
After I had my bone density test done (in which they told me I had osteoporosis) the doctor there said that he has this wonderful new research that I may qualify for and it involves this great new drug. At the moment this drug is incredibly expensive, but if I join the research group, I can try it for free! Well, all the red lights started flashing for me! Soon after that I found an integrative doctor who agreed with me and he hates those drugs! I finally feel as if my doctor and I are working as a team and together with the information you have given me, we will rebuild actual bone mass. Incidentally, I’m 53, very active, eat very healthy, no history of osteoporosis in my family, never broken a bone…no risk factors at all! My integrative doctor is incredibly skeptical of the bone scan results!
January 11, 2009
Hi Vivian, This is an answer to your e-mail dated 1/11/2009 asking for comments on the future of osteoporosis. Your first scenario seems like a replay of todays pharmaceutical companies and I hope we don’t have to wait for 2050 to realize a correction. If we don’t learn from todays disaters, Vioxx, HRT’s, Osteoporosis Drugs, etc., etc., nothing will change in the future. We need to spread the good news we learn from you to everyone who will listen including our doctors. Hopefully by 2050 we will be using natural remedies and we will not have drug companies killing us.
January 9, 2009
Hi Vi, I enjoy your E-mails very much.My wife & I try to eat healthy, but NOT always easy, considering what we have to work with in our area. My wife’s mother is the one who has the osteoporosis, so bad. However, since I have gotten her Dr. at her Nursing home to take her off one of her drugs(for which we couldn’t figure out why she was prescribed to have it, in the 1st place) and has gotten her on a double dose of Calcium & Vitamin D(2 times/day),she seems to be coming along much better.It really hard to get her to eat properly. She loves tomatoes, but too much of a good thing can be bad, especially when you don’t eat enough of other wholesome foods.I have downloaded Christopher Vasey’s Acid-Alkaine Foods Chart from phionBalance.com. I have found that to be VERY Good! You should check out their website at http://www.phionbalance.com! They have some some nice recipes as well. I waiting to hear more about these drug companies going bankrupt! Serves them darn RIGHT for screwing around with our health, like they have for the past 50 years! Sincerely, Phil
January 5, 2009
Hi Vivian
Thank you for all your research into bone density I get a lot of good info out of your emails and after studying your book have found that I am on the right track as I have an alkerlizer that takes all the acid out of the water and helps in keeping the Ph in the body at a better level I am 69 and keep fit with exercises and take no other supplements at the moment the exercises seem to help to keep the pain levels down
many thanks again for your assisisance
Regards Rex
January 4, 2009
Vivian,
I absolutely love your emails! I forward them to my gyno’s office, his wife is the office manager there and I want her to know all this information so he can pass it on to his patients.
I use Nature Made products for calcium and the other supplements that I take. But I was wondering if you had products that were proven to be effective. I wanted to let you know that I had fallen on the ice last week. Thank God that I had my longer coat on because I fell on my hip and shoulder. I thought that I would be sore for a while, but the next day I was fine. I contribute that to exercise, eating a healthy diet and my strong bones (no matter what the doctor said). I know that I am healthy.
Thank you for the wonderful information.
Sincerely,
Donna
January 3, 2009
Thanks for all the info Vivian, I enjoy reading everyone comments, makes me feel I am on the right track with what I am taking, I have switched my reverse osmosis water as I found the water to be acid, I now have another water filter with an added calcium filter, so now my tests show that I am more alkaline, which is great as I drink quite a lot of water.
December 28, 2008
I was told about a negative Dexa test 3 years ago and my doctor just told me to increase my calcium, magnesium, and vitamin D. But after 2 years the results of the next Dexa test were so negative that the doctor told me I had osteoporosis (lost almost 2 inches) and prescribed Fosamax. I refused to take it because my sisters’ doctor warned her not to take it – that it would be dangerous because she has reflux. That was when I looked on the internet for an alternative solution and got your book “Bone Health Revolution”. I like any thing that is a natural alternative. I do Reiki and Tai Ch and yoga for exercise and I make my own heart pills for my high cholesterol (hereditery problem) so I loved your book. I believe keeping your body with a balanced PH is the answer to most health problems.
The person that asked about TriVita”s bone builder supplement sounds simular to the GNC bone density vites that I take and a friend of mine got a possitive Dexa test after taking them for only one year. I get another Dexa next year.
Other acid- alkaline lists claim Soy milk as acid. I have troulble staying away from breads because I went Vegetarian and eat so many veggie sandwiches. How would a Ph level be with these since I have to eat a lot of beans,eggs and cheese? Your feedback is important to me. Thanks.
November 28, 2008
it would be nice to be around to find out just what the future results will finally be, it would be very nice to find a natural cure that would have no cemical effect at all, but use only a cure from nature its self.
November 23, 2008
Wow! And thank you -Is all I can say after reading your book. My Doctor is really after me to “take something ” for my bones.She wants me to take either Forto or Zometa–well I looked them up on the web and also after reading your book–no way! I take vitamins B,C,E and calcium. I switched to the new Caltrate with the bone builder and am also taking magesium and vitamin D. I have six months before my next bone scan so I hope to see a great improvement when I have it. What do you think of the new Caltrate with Genistine?
November 23, 2008
I greatly appreciate your contacts and research about osteoporosis. I prefer to avoid drugs and try diet and would love more details on that please. Must give the watermelon a try.
What is your opinion on Cementex – sounds a bit drastic, stiffening of joints, knees, elbows and fingers plus $200 discount towards wheelchair – not ready for that yet!! Keep up your great work. Val
November 21, 2008
Elaine : Thanks for sharing your comments. While strontium does not have dangerous side-effects, it is denser than calcium and can therefore show greater bone density on the DEXA scan (which is misleading).
Regards,
Vivian
November 21, 2008
Margaret: You’re right. I am hopeful that the pain will improve. If you have not tried it yet, you might want to take a vitamin B complex supplement…it might help you.
All the best,
Vivian
November 21, 2008
Cookie: Sounds great! I’m so glad your bone density increased in your hips…it’s so inspiring to hear such good results after one year.
And thanks for sharing a great tip. Watermelon is high in lycopene, which has a very positive effect on bones.
Keep in touch,
Vivian
November 21, 2008
Aline: I am sure your efforts to improve your bone health will show great results. Keep it up!
To answer your question about the supplement, the ingredients are fine, but it is not clear whether the MCHC (microcrystalline hydroxyapatite) is really that much more effective than other forms of calcium. One study was done in 1995 with 40 people where it did show improved results, but obviously it was a very small study. There is an issue with it also because MCHC is derived from bovine bone. In the 1980s, bone meal calcium supplements were found to be contaminated with heavy metals…in an ideal world I would recommend the product, but from pasture-fed, free-range livestock not subjected to routine antibiotics or rBGH.
Take care,
Vivian
November 20, 2008
hi, everything is so confusing. I thought I was doing everything right –just had a bone density test and was a little lower than 2 years ago. I don’t want to take meds but what else is there? Heredity counts for some too, right? What’s the best natural thing out there? I need to get better, am almost at the bottom of the chart.
November 20, 2008
Thank you for the information on Cementex. I will see my doctor tomorrow and will ask how she perceives its effectiveness.
November 18, 2008
Vivian..I print every piece of information you send me. It’s too important not to. I file it in with your book you sent me for further information.
Right now I’m taking pro-adjustments from a Chiropractor here in Sun City. The interesting thing about her is she’s on Boniva and don’t know what else to do. I gave her your website and I’m sure she will be in contact with you.
In reading your website mail I have a question. Why would they want to go back and have a density test knowing all the info you have put out on these machines? Why would they even want to go back to a Dr. who diagnosed them with a death sentence? Forgive me for being so questionable.
Thanks Vivian,
Darlene F. Doerfler
November 18, 2008
G DAY VIVIAN THANKYOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT AND DETAIL IMFORMATION ON CEMENTEX,MY GP HAS WIPED ME COMPLETELY SINCE I CHOSE TWO GO DRUG FREE ACTONEL AND FOSAMAX.I HAVE MENTIONED A SIMILAR TREATMENT TWO CEMENTEX HE WOULD NOT GO THERE.I WONDER IF THIS TREATMENT IS BEING PRESCRIBED IN AUSTRALIA.MY NEXT APPOINTMENT WITH HIM IS 4TH DEC.I HAVE TWO REQUEST A BONE DENSITY TEST AND I WILL BE ENQUIRING ABOUT CEMENETEX.IT SHOULD BE AN INTERESTING APPOINTMENT.KIND REGARDS STEPHEN GRIFFIN.
November 17, 2008
Dear Vivian:
Thank you so much for all your very informant emails. Please continue to send
them. Enjoyed reading everyones comments. Hope I am helped by all the info.
Thanks again, Janet Barbera
November 16, 2008
Hi Vivian: Thank you so much for all the research you have done on osteoporosis and ostopenia. Not only that, but also sharing your findings with those of us with these conditions. I am trying to follow your advice and I really appreciate the information you have been sending by email. My next bone density test is sscheduled for May, 2009 and I am anxious to see if my scores have improved. Thanks again, Bonnie Holloway.
November 16, 2008
Thank you for the update, personally I would not jump into having my bones injected with this new product until it has been out there in the open world for a few years.
I am flabergasted that the bone density score ,of my 65 year old body being put up against the standards of a 20 year olds. Doesn’t make sense to me.
Too many products in the past which were the then “one to end all” have now been removed from the shelves.
I have increased my calcium and am now looking into the new recommended increase of Vitamin D.
With the onset of winter, I can no longer do my earthbox gardening(major source of exercise) so I have just joined a gym. I am doing standard range of motion patterns as warm up and using some of the equipment (without weights) to assess my muscle responses. I’ll ad weight as tolerated later.
I am a retired Occupational Therapist,I have moderate/severe scoliosis with stenosis of the spine that provides for multiple aches, pain and such. I just can not bring myself to take synthetic drugs knowing the potential side effects to my still healthy organs.
Gentle active exercise and gentle resistive exercise is essential to retain flexibility.
November 16, 2008
Dear Vivian,
It has been a long time since I’ve e-mail you.
Well I have been faced with a lot of health problems over the past year.
I’ve lot several inches in height so my doctor odered a MRI of my spine.
Oh – I have a fractured L-4 and a Slipped L-5 vertabra. I have been getting steriod injection in my back to try and help ease the lower back pain. So far I;ve recieved little to relief, and I;m supossed to have another on the 26th of Nov.
I have always thought that steroids can cause bone lose but Dr. says NO.
I also have been told that I have Fibromyalgia. Extreme muscle and joint pain. the weather plays a big factor in how I feel. Heat bothers me cold bothers me and the only thing that I have found that help is a product called OPC-3 or opcextra.
I have been taking 1000 I.U. of V.-D,
1000 Calcium, 400 of Magnesium and V.-K. My last bone desity test I was told that I had ostoporosis very bad.
I will not take the trash that is prescribed by the Doctor’s, I have a very understanding Doctor and she has been taking courses in Alternative Med.
thank you for all you help and letting me bend you ear. Any and all suggestions would be welcome.
Mardel
November 15, 2008
Dear Vivian
Thank you for your reserach and your book. I do enjoy your e-mails with osteoporosis news. I am trying my best to keep to the PH diet – not too hard as I love fruit and vegetables and I found the recipes in the book very good.
I am a retired physiotherapist so naturally I believe in exercise and I was interested in Simplecise. I have started doing that.
i am fortunate to have only occasional slight back pain. I wonder if those who have pain have tried Reiki or energy healing. As you know I am English but I know that these are available in the States.
November 15, 2008
My gynocologist has intstilled the fear of God in me. He has made me so afraid not to take the drugs, but I am even more afraid to take them. I actually think he is probably going to quit seeing me if I do not. You have given me hope. My spine is a negtive 2.9 and my hip and leg bones are a negative 2.5. He tries to tell me I have not choice but to take the drugs. I have tried two which have given me stomach problems. Like so many other drugs on the market, I am afraid down the road we are going to hear of the terrible results of taking them. Please keep doing the good work you are doing. I am going to see a new doctor next week who is in to alternative medicine. I can’t wait to hear what he has to say about these medications.
November 15, 2008
I love reading your views on bone health….I went to your web site when the Dr told me she was going to start me on fosamax….Turned out she had me mixed up with someone else. Thank God……She told me I had great bone health and to keep doing what ever I was doing. I turned 59 today and may treat myself to you book. I love prevention. and like the second version of your senerio. I have a thyroid problem. Will your suggestions interfer with my synthroid. I have hyshemoto. Thanks for taking the time to study bone health Valerie
November 15, 2008
Thank you so much for all your information
How ever, I do not know what your book contains & have not as yet ordered it.
I can not take Fosomax, as I read an article on the computer, saying it is not advisable to take if one has had a stroke or heart attack. As I have had a minor stroke some two years ago, I decided not to take Fosomax. I then saw my doctor, who luckily had seen the same article, & so agreed with me not to take Fosamax, which he had prescribed just a few days earlier. My doctor then referred me to an endocrinologist, to find out what I could take for my osteoporosis ie Lumber spine T-score -2.3, & Left femoral neck T-score -2.8.
The endocrinologist was in favour of Fosamax. He said that there was not a conclusive evedence that there is an increased incidence of atrial fibrilation associated with biophosphonate therapy. (these are his words)
However I told hom I was not going to take Fosamax. He then prescribed me OsteVit-D or VitaminD3 1000 iu, to take one a day, which I have now been taking for about 2 months. I also take one Ultra Calcium tablet a day, which I have taken for a number of years, because of my osteoporosis, which I have had for several years now. I am 78 years of age.
I really thought that the endocrinologist would be able to prescribe something instead of fosamax, but apparantly not so. He wishes to see me in another year. Probably will again have to have my bone mineral density measurements taken.
Thank you Vivian for all your information on the computer, but I have not as yet decided to buy your book, as I don`t know or understand what you may have in mind.
Sincerely,
Marion
July 1, 2009
I loved the analagies and the clever names you “came up”with.
Others that have emailed their response are interesting as well. My story is this:
I had been on Boniva (once a month pill) for two and a half years (doctor prescribed) and was tired of paying $109.00 for each pill (no insurance). I was searching the web sites for a better price on Boniva when I noticed a little ad to one side of the page that had an ad for Vivian’s book “The Bone Revolution” and maybe a statement on “what you really don’t know about osteoporosis”.
I am 84 years young: active: and I cut Boniva off “cold turkey” after reading Vivian’s research and book.
Thanks Vivian for keeping in touch email as well. Those that have not started with the book, SHOULD! It makes a difference even if you “eat well” already.
November 15, 2008
I love the articles. Everybody sounds so up-beat and positive and I hope some of it will rub off on me!!!
I have developed “frozen shoulder” and the pain is at the acute stage and a good nights sleep is a thing of the past!! I have started a course of acupuncture and have had my first physical therapy session. I can manage the pain during the day but the nights!!!! Any suggestions from anybody?
November 15, 2008
I am hoping to have knee reconstruction on both knees. As my Dr’s report says I have almost ‘total obliteration of the cartilages on both knees’
I have never been able to stomach any form of chemical pain killers I have osteo-arthritis etc, and Glucosamine is all I can take. Pain is still there and stiffness also.
Does cartilage ever grow again? Is there nothing that I can do, but wait for the surgery to be able to walk pain free again?
As it is it’s getting almost unbearable at times to even stay up to sit and enjoy watching TV or to just sit.
November 14, 2008
I got osteoporosis in my back when I had a steroid shot in my back for pain. No warning that it might thin my bones. The literature says boniva, fosamax, etc. prevent the bone loss. I said “no” but no more shots. I quit my last internist when he was so persistant about trying to make me take the pills I wouldn’t take. It reminded me of a former doctor who insisted I must take hormone replacement therapy. The drug companies really have brainwashed the doctors and have advocates in them. Thank you for your book & your information. They help give me the strength to keep saying “NO”. I have been taking ezorb & will get another bone test in January. I have an inner ear problem that causes imbalance & I sometimes fall but having younger, more flexible bone instead of old, brittle bone has proven good for me.
Thank you,
Jeanne Litteer
Atlanta, Georgia
November 14, 2008
I have stopped for about 8 months now taking any meds for osteoporisis in my spine. I have had bad stomach problems from Fosamax and Actonal and therefore stopped against my doctors orders. I don’t have any pains and walk on the sand/beach for 45 minutes almost daily. I dance very aerobically 2 hours at a time 2 times a week. I feel fine but worry about not taking meds for osteo. I have read and printed articles written by qualified researchers that blame Fosamax for atrial fib which I developed out of the blue sky. The afib is transient but I now must take Coumaden. I only have had a few episodes and they quickly revert back to normal. I always thought that how could I have this atrial fib when all my heart tests are negative. The doctors won’t address this at all even though the studies show that Fosamax can cause atrial fib. What the heck can we do??? I also take the calcium, magnesium, vitamin D and boron as you suggest.
November 14, 2008
Loved the scenarios, Vivian! I have been very motivaed, thanks to you and your dedicated research into this subject, to continue to carefully monitor my daily intake of acids/alkalines. And I try to find the best calcium supplement at an affordable price that I can. Some of the extraordinarily good ones are just out of my price range. But I try to at least go for calcium citrate which I researched to be better than oyster or carbonate. (I’ll have to get your opinion on that.) I haven’t had a second bone scan to compare to the first, because I really am in no rush to have such an unreliable test again. And I do believe that any time a drug company is involved in something like this, a healthy scepticism is the best approach. Thank you for adding substance to that initial unease!
Eva
November 14, 2008
I am pleased to receive so much information from you, Vivian!
I am not taking any prescription drugs for osteoporosis/ osteopenia as I had reactions to several drugs which I was given i.e. Actonel, Didrocal.These made me deathly ill.
I am taking 681 mg of strontium citrate( supplement) daily; made by AOR, a company in Calgary, Alberta, Canada. I watch my diet also.I am doing weight- bearing exercises. I am a strong 70 yr old female now.
Sincerely,
Elaine Langdon
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
November 14, 2008
Vivian, thank you -thank you – thank you!
I read your book and did a lot of research. No more “soap suds” for me. I started to follow the D, Calcium and magnesium like a religion. Followed your diet and exercise advice. Results after one year – bone density test revealed no change in my spine and more positive change in the hips! I am 72 and I feel great. It is very important to rid the body of acids (a result of the chemicals in our food) in a natural way. Take a day of eating just watermelon, as much as you like and drink lots of water. Your joints will be cleansed and you will feel the difference. I try to do this at least once a month.
November 14, 2008
Vivian, I am thrilled to have access to your website. Great article and I love the blog.
I would like to know if you are familiar with TriVita’s Bone Builder suplement. It contains
1000 IU Vitamin D; 1000 mg Calcium; 600 mcg Vitamin K; 400 mg magnesium and other vitamins. It is a patented formula that they have tested to build bone density. I have been taking this for a few months but will not have another bone density test until May 2009. I just wanted to know what your thoughts are on this supplement.
I have really been trying to keep a good PH balance and I truly believe this is the key to the success of treating osteoporosis. Thanks for the research you are doing and in this area.
AH
June 28, 2009
I refuse to take the prescription drugs for osteoporosis. I am taking calcium supplementsnwith D+K. I will have a bone density test done in Sept. 2009, hope it works, However I did take bonivia about 2 years ago, had a very bad expierence with just 1 (one) pill. Just wondering what the turned out was, since the test was done May of 2009, would appreciate a reply.
Thanks,
Sandra
July 5, 2009
VIVIAN, I REALLY DON’T KNOW WHAT TO DO? I HAVE CEREBRAL PALSY, OSTEOPOROSIS, VIT D DEFICIENCY AND A KNEE REPLACEMENT 2YRS AGO. NOT SUPPOSED TO FALL SO I HAVE A POWERCHAIR AT HOME. CONSEQUENTLY I’M NON WEIGHT BEARING FOR THE MOST PART. NEED THE OTHER KNEE REPLACED AND THE LEFT SHOULDER. BEEN TAKING VIT D WITH CALCIUM AND MY READING IS NOW 34, IT WAS 24 LAST YR. TOOK ACTINOL AND BONIVA, HAD VERY BAD SIDE EFFECTS! MY ENDOCRINOLOGIST WANTS ME TO TRY INJECTABLE BONIVA EVERY 3MOS. I READ HORROR STORIES ON THIS. HE TOLD ME I AM A PROBLEM AND WHERE WAS I GETTING MY INFO? I AM GOING TO ORDER YOUR BOOK SOON. THANK YOU FOR CARING ABOUT THIS.
VIVIAN L.
November 14, 2008
Excellent, exciting scenarios. Let us hope for their realization. No longer would I need to hear from my doctor, “If you fall, that’s the end of you.” Yes, he really said that, but I could hear between the lines: “Someone is pressuring me to pressure you, and I have to comply.” The upshot of that short sentence put me almost flat on my back, not with fear, but with anger, which lasted three months. I welcome the day doctors no longer frighten us into submission. I tell you the truth. They have been trying it with me since the beginning of the seventies.
To be more specific, I should tell you that I have a severe pain problem, which most likely is neuropathic. It has no name and no treatment. My feet feel like a bundle of rocks, and the pains shoot higher and higher up my body. Thus I am unable to exercise as recommended, but I do eat right. I have found the line I must walk between too much movement and too little. However, this pain has robbed me of much of who I am and what I used to do. It’s unfortunate that along with osteoporosis, problems originating in the brain, and many others the medical profession has no answers except drugs to try to cover up the symptoms.
Thank you, Vivian, for your help and inspiration.
June 17, 2009
Vivian, I ordered your book several weeks ago and paid for it with my credit card, have not received it yet. Please let me know the status on it please.
Thanks,
Carolyn Boren
July 7, 2009
To Margaret Preble: your doctor said “if you fall that’s the end of you”. I remember back in the days of HRT, a doctor telling my friend “If you don’t take HRT your body will fall apart”! She’s still waiting!
Good luck to you with your neuropathy. My mother had the same thing, I know it’s awful.
July 13, 2009
I too had terrible pain in my feet for years and couldn’t walk more that short distances. At the end of a day the pain would radiate into my legs and keep me awake. I found a product called Yoga Toes, there are cheaper knock offs available. The difference is no short of a Miracle. I hope this will help you. It has certainly changed my life!!!
November 14, 2008
Try Alpha Lipoic Acid – 300 mg. 1 2x a day.
Research is on http://www.webmd.com Great aticle written in 2003!
I have neuropathy in my feet – cause unknown -I am not diabetic.
Good luck!
November 15, 2008
How Do I send this to you?
November 15, 2008
You need a CranioSacral Therapist or an Osteopathic Manipulation Medicine Pain Management D.O. to work on you from a natural stand point. Both these fields approach pain from the point of assisting your body to heal itself. You can look on line for both these specialties in your location.
December 2, 2008
First I took shots of Cortisone (about 3 a yr.) and then went to a clinic called “Back In Motion” in Sarasota, Fl. where I received several treatments of low level cold laser along with exercise therapy and massage. I am happy to say I have NO PAIN in my shoulder at all and have used this therapy for several other painful joints which it has helped tremendously. I do have advanced osteop. and take calcium citrate, D, and mag. I found I was very low in my Vit. D and took 50,000 units once a wk for 8 wks and built it up to 67 instead of the very low 19. (Should be around 60- to 70 for normal test results.) Good luck. Best from Sherrie
January 3, 2009
I had a frozen right sdhoulder for a year then again last year in my left shoulder I tried most things then I heard about laser treatment at my local naturapath, after about six treatments I recovered, she also injected msm with other natural components. I would highly recomend the treatment for frozen shoulder, I know it was the best cure for me, now living pain free, with full motion in my shoulders.
January 19, 2009
Get an inversion table. My boyfriend has a compression fracture of his L5 and this table was the best thing ever for help with that. There was a time when drying his feet off in the shower when he pulled his back out of place and needed a walker to get around. That was over a year ago.
January 25, 2009
Ruth: you’re bringing up a very important point. This article simply shows two possibilities with completely different outcomes. I wrote it because it’s a way to make us think about our health in a different way.
I believe that health practitioners mean well and that they care about their patients.And I agree with you: there is no “perfect system”.
My philosophy is that knowledge is power and that we are free to make choices about our health.
Best regards,
Vivian
August 11, 2009
Dear Vivian,
I already bought stontium citrate. I stopped taking my actonel and thinking of taking strontium instead. I can’t keep tract of all the intake of all the good food and vitamins. I’m so busy that I would like to take a short cut by taking stontium to build my bones. Of course with vitamins too.
That’s another struggle for me finding the best vitamins for someone who is very acidic. I took Camatrix calcium and I vomitted,and had diarrhea and migraine. I was so sick after a week of taking it. Please advise what is the best calcium for acidic people like me?
I’m scared of all these medicines !!!!!!
Please email at : ninicoran@yahoo.ca
I’m not sure if this is okay to inquire.
Thanks,
nini