A New Prescription For Bone Health: Exercise - Save Our Bones

In March of 2015, my mother received a cutting-edge medical intervention that may very well have saved her life.

I went with her to see her doctor for a regular check-up on the week of her 90th birthday. He took her blood pressure and other vital signs. Fortunately, everything looked good. Then, without fanfare, he asked a question I had never heard a doctor ask before. “Do you go on walks?” She said no.

His response was shocking, and as it turns out, ahead of its time. You'll learn what he did a little later, but first, let's expand on his unusual question. He asked about my mother's physical activity– something that most doctors typically ignore.

A Call To Action From Doctors, To Doctors

In 2016 something remarkable happened. A collection of widely respected doctors banded together to expand on what the Medical Establishment prescribes.

They published a special report in the journal of the American College of Sports Medicine. The report called on other physicians to make physical activity assessment and prescription a standard part of medical care.

They begin their call to action by reviewing the 60-year history of growing concern over declining physical activity levels among Americans. Despite actions taken over that time, the U.S population is rife with low cardiorespiratory fitness, and sedentary lifestyles.

These factors are associated with chronic illnesses that have been endemic in the United States. In fact, physical inactivity is a public health crisis.

In response, this group of doctors proposes a new standard practice. This new approach would place exercise front and center in a doctor's most basic assessment of a patient's health. They propose the universal implementation of a Physical Activity Vital Sign (PAVS).


A group of doctors published a report calling for the universal implementation of a Physical Activity Vital Sign (PAVS), as a means to address and reverse the continued trend of sedentary lifestyles among Americans.

Physical Activity Is A Vital Sign

My mother's doctor provided an excellent example of how assessing physical activity as a vital sign would work. He asked if she took walks. That's a very specific question about physical activity based on his knowledge of my mother's age and physical condition. But generally, the assessment of physical activity would be much broader.

The report gives the example of PAVS questions used by a variety of forward-thinking institutions such as Kaiser Permanente and Greenville Health Systems:1

“On average, how many days per week do you engage in moderate
to strenuous physical activity (like a brisk walk)?

On average, how many minutes do you engage in physical
activity at this level?”

The answers are recorded and considered alongside other data about the patient's health. For patients not meeting the CDC's recommended 150 minutes per week of moderate to vigorous physical activity, a prescription is in order.

But not a prescription for a drug– a prescription for more physical activity.


Physicians can assess physical activity as a vital sign by asking patients about the frequency and duration of their time engaging in exercise. If patients do not meet the recommended minimum of 150 minutes of moderate to vigorous exercise per week, then the doctors would prescribe an increase in physical activity.

Exercise As A First-Line Treatment

Physical inactivity poses serious and immediate health risks. Physicians have a responsibility to inform their patients of those risks. Then they can give their patients a prescription that could save their lives.

Unlike other prescriptions a doctor might offer, this non-pharmaceutical intervention has only positive side-effects. And unlike any drug, the positive health benefits are numerous. They support a wide array of body systems– including the bone remodeling process.

This is what the report had to say about adopting exercise as a first-line treatment:

“Regular physical activity should be advocated for the prevention and first-line treatment of chronic disease. The default exercise prescription is to walk at least 30 minutes a day, 5 or more days per week, with a target of Q150 minutes per week of moderate-intensity physical activity. It should be noted that any type of physical activity done at a moderate pace would count toward this weekly goal.

However, when previously sedentary patients initiate an exercise program, level walking should be strongly recommended, gradually increasing the walking speed or intensity of exertion over time (2 to 3 months), provided they remain asymptomatic (20). This strategy may decrease the likelihood of injury or cardiovascular event and increase cardiorespiratory fitness. An effort also should be made to recommend activities that people enjoy and will likely continue to engage in over time.”1

The recommendation of this report has been echoed by other medical professionals. Robert Sallis of Kaiser Permanente Medical Center published an editorial in favor of an exercise vital sign which concluded that “such an approach is critical to help stem the rising tide of deaths around the world due to noncommunicable diseases, which are so closely associated with a sedentary lifestyle.”2

The Medical Establishment has continued to resist making a PAVS assessment and prescription standard for physicians across the country. We continue to see the tragic results of sedentary lifestyles.


Exercise should be a first-line treatment for the prevention of the serious health risks posed by physical inactivity. Doctors should ask about physical activity levels and prescribe an increase when necessary. This recommendation for the prevention of unnecessary suffering and death has been echoed by other medical professionals, but the Medical Establishment has not made it a standard of care.

What This Means To You

The Save Institute was founded with the knowledge of the power of exercise. That's why it is built into the Osteoporosis Reversal Program, and why we created SaveTrainer. It provides robust support for creating a personalized program of physical activity that ensures that this vital sign is strong in every Saver.

If you haven't already guessed, when my mother's doctor learned that she wasn't going on walks, his response was perfectly in line with the recommendation for a Physical Activity Vital Sign. He pulled out his prescription pad. But instead of prescribing a drug that would have awful side effects and little measurable impact, he wrote a different prescription– one for a daily dose of 30-minute walks.

This past March, my mother celebrated her 95th birthday, and she's doing great!


1 https://www.exerciseismedicine.org/assets/page_documents/Call_to_Action_on_Making_Physical_Activity.19.pdf

2 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00913847.2015.1001938

The Top 14 Things You’re Doing That Are Damaging Your Bones... And More!

  • Stop The Bone Thieves! report
  • Email course on how to prevent and reverse bone loss
  • Free vital osteoporosis news and updates.
Get It Free Now

Comments on this article are closed.

  1. Joyce

    Your presentation for improving digestion sounded wonderful. I plan to start doing some of these things right away and gradually work in the others,

  2. Don

    What if you have mild neuropathy in your feet (not diabetic), have lower back pain and you have osteopenia? After 15 minutes walking I start to have mild balance issues and increasing back pain. Is there an alternative form of exercise you can recommend?

    PS Who says 6’3″ men can’t get osteoporosis?

    • Vivian Goldschmidt, MA

      Don, I’m sorry you have to be dealing with those issues! I suggest getting a treadmill so it’ll be easy to walk in 15-minute intervals and you can hold on to the sides for balance and stability.

      For more information on treadmills and bone health, I suggest you read this article:


      I hope it will work for you!

      • Joyce

        As soon as the pools open, walking in the water is a less scary way of getting aerobic exercise. Not as good as walking but beneficial when you can’t do the land work,

  3. Rosie

    My wonderful Mum used to walk regularly, well into her 90’s, telling her peers “put that stick away, stand up straight and walk smartly!” Now here I am, at 75 walking smartly each day and convinced I am morphing into Mum! I believe the legs are the levers we use to work a healthy heart and head 😊😊

    • Vivian Goldschmidt, MA

      Congrats, Rosie! And well said 🙂

  4. Linda

    Would indoor walking workouts like Leslie Sansone’s Walk at Home count for walking exercise?

  5. Beverly Jackson

    Hi Vivian When I go to the doctor the always ask me about my exercise regiment. I exercise everyday and I walk everyday. One of my doctor said to me if all my patients were like you I would not make any money. I am not on any medication. You are right the New Prescription is Exercise. I have given your Website to a number of women and they were so happy to find out about the osteoporosis medicine that they shouldn’t take. Thank you so much for all of your help and the information that give.

    • Vivian Goldschmidt, MA

      That’s quite a special doctor, Beverly. You’re fortunate to have found him! And I thank you for spreading the word about Save Our Bones!

  6. K. Gopal Rao

    I am aged 81, and i consider myself reasonably fit as I hv been exercising all my life, from schooldays onwards. Lately mu son has urged me to cut down to to abt 3-4 hrs per week, and I hv done so. However, when I do a 1-hr workout, either bodywt or resistance, fairly intensive, I find myself sleeping for 10hrs that night. Isn’t it too much of sleep? Is it a sign that I need to cut down either intensity or duration? Vivian and others, may I have yr advice.

    • Vivian Goldschmidt, MA

      It’s great that you’ve been so active all those years! You should try to do shorter workout sessions, like 30 minutes, and see what happens with your sleep cycle. I hope this helps!

  7. Connie Haman

    That’s fantastic that exercise is being addressed. Now if they would start asking about diet maybe there would less preventable disease.

    • Vivian Goldschmidt, MA

      You’re making a very good point, Connie 🙂

  8. Kate Kerr

    We definitely need more Doctors like him.

    • Vivian Goldschmidt, MA

      Absolutely, Kate!

  9. Crystal

    Finally some common sense from doctors. I hope that at least some doctors will take their advice. Thanks so much for letting us know, Vivian!

    • Vivian Goldschmidt, MA

      I hope so too, Crystal! And you’re very welcome 🙂

Get Started With Your FREE
Natural Bone Building Kit.

Get a free copy of our ‘Stop The Bone Thieves’ eBook, exclusive content that you can’t find anywhere else, plus vital osteoporosis news and updates.

Get It Free

Get Your Free Bone-Building Kit


‘Stop The Bone Thieves’ guide, exclusive info, plus vital osteoporosis news and updates.