Dirty Vs Clean Alcohol? Which Alcoholic Beverages Should You Avoid And Which Are The Safest - Save Our Bones

Savers already know that an occasional alcoholic beverage won’t undermine a bone-smart diet or lifestyle. But what is not so well-known is that several popular beers and wines contain toxic ingredients.

Now is a good time to become aware of these harmful toxins – summer celebrations, cookouts, and picnics are in full swing in the Northern Hemisphere, and alcoholic beverages are often served to provide refreshment. And of course, they are popular year-round, so this information is relevant throughout the year as well.

Today you’ll learn which ingredients you should avoid and the drinks that are best for your bones, so the occasional enjoyment of an “adult beverage” won’t add to your toxic load.

But first, there’s an important point I want to address about the acidifying nature of alcohol.

Is Alcohol Acidifying?

All alcoholic drinks, regardless of the presence of toxic ingredients, are acidifying. However, this does not mean that alcohol is off-limits on the Program. For example, beer contains silicon, and red wine contains the antioxidant resveratrol.

Balance and moderation are far more important concepts to the Program than restricting certain foods, but bear in mind that as you choose healthful options for alcohol, it should still be counted as part of the 20% acidifying foods and drinks on the Program’s 80/20 nutritional plan.

This is why, at the Save Institute, we recommend balancing alcoholic beverages with an alkalizing snack or meal to offset the acidifying effects of the alcohol.

What makes alcohol acidifying? After all, some alcoholic drinks, like wine, are made from grapes, which are alkalizing. But when those grapes are fermented, alcohol – more correctly, ethanol – is produced, and ethanol is acidifying.

Scientific Research Backs Up Alcohol’s Acidifying Nature

Thirty volunteers in “a fasting state” were given ethanol, and blood and urine samples were taken at various intervals after ingestion. Urine pH decreased significantly, particularly at three and seven hours after ingestion. The study scientists concluded that:

“…urine acidification after ethanol ingestion is related with serum acetaldehyde concentration.”1

Acetaldehyde is the substance produced when your body metabolizes ethanol.
But there are many ingredients in alcoholic beverages besides ethanol, and that’s what I want to share with you next.

Following is a list of toxic ingredients, so you’ll have your own mental “label” to help you make healthful choices.

Toxic Ingredients Commonly Found In Alcohol

1. Pesticides

Conventionally grown grapes are one of the most heavily-sprayed crops (they rank #6 in the EWG’s latest Dirty Dozen list). And wine, like grape juice, is a concentrated form of the fruit, so the amount of pesticide residue will be much greater in a cup of wine than a cup of whole grapes. Unless a wine is labeled “organic,” you can’t be sure that you’re not ingesting bone-damaging pesticides.

A note about organic labeling – pay attention to the wording. If it says “made with organic grapes,” then it may contain more sulfites than if the wine is simply labeled “organic”.

2. Sulfur Dioxide

Usually shortened to “sulfites” or “sulphites,” sulfur dioxide occurs naturally to some degree in all wines, in various forms and amounts. But naturally-occurring sulfites are generally in a very low concentration, whereas commercial, mass-produced wines, where every batch must taste the same, may contain significant amounts of sulfites.

Wine manufacturers add sulfur dioxide as a preservative. It makes wine shelf-stable at room temperature, which most people attribute to the wine’s alcohol content. But that’s not why your bottle of wine doesn’t “go bad” when it sits on the countertop during the summer. It’s actually the sulfur dioxide.

How much sulfur dioxide is added varies greatly by brand, quality of grapes, and other factors. Wine makers may add more sulfur dioxide to one batch than another. And therein lies the problem – a wine may have a vague label saying “contains sulfites,” but no reference to the milligrams per liter.

Another factor influences how much sulfite is added to wine. When wine makers add the sulfites, some of the molecules become “bound” to other elements in the wine, rendering the sulfites useless as a preservative. So manufacturers must add enough sulfur dioxide that there will be plenty of “free” sulfites available after binding takes place. For example, wines with a lot of added sugar will likely contain greater amounts of sulfur dioxide, because sugar binds with the sulfite molecules.

Sulfur dioxide can cause allergic reactions, such as skin flushing and headaches, and it can exacerbate asthma.

3. GMOs

Many alcoholic drinks, such as vodka are corn-based (corn is rapidly replacing potatoes as the base for vodka), and corn is one of the major GM crops. Other drinks, including beer, may contain not only corn, but corn derivatives like GMO corn syrup.

4. Animal Products

Animal products are not toxic per se, but the odd animal parts – such as fish bladder (sometimes listed as “isinglass”) – are not necessarily something you’d want to ingest unknowingly. And for vegans, products like gelatin, found in various alcoholic drinks, are off-limits. Those who have ethical concerns about consuming animal products will certainly want to know if there are any such products in whatever food or beverage they’re consuming.

4. “Natural” Flavors And Artificial Colors

The vague term “natural flavors” denotes any flavoring agent that has a natural source…but the end product may be anything but natural. A good illustration of this is monosodium glutamate, a dubious substance that has been linked to skin rashes, migraines, and even heart irregularities. But if its source is something natural, such as vegetables or fruits, then it can be claimed to be a “natural flavor.”

Consuming a substance in low amounts as it occurs naturally in a food is entirely different than consuming it in high concentrations after it’s been extracted from the food and added to another food or beverage.

Additionally, artificial colors abound in various alcoholic drinks, especially those that are flavored, such as FD&C Yellow #5, FD&C Blue #1, FD&C Red 40, caramel color, and other toxic food dyes are all potential additives.

6. BPA

The container your alcoholic beverage is stored in makes a difference. Most cans contain plastic linings with BPA, and plastic bottles, jugs, and boxed wine containers may also contain it. BPA, or bisphenol A, is a known calcium-blocker that has been linked to birth defects, cancer of the breast and prostate, early puberty, impaired immunity, neurological impairment, and other grave health concerns. Glass bottles are a safe option.

7. Arsenic

A known carcinogen, arsenic has been found in wines in varying amounts, mainly in wines produced in California, New York, Washington and Oregon. Because arsenic occurs naturally in the soil, the actual levels of this chemical in wine are difficult to pinpoint. Some wines consistently contain more than others, with some containing four and five times the amount allowed by the EPA in drinking water. You may have heard of this because it was widely reported by the media.

Choosing organic wine decreases the chance that it will contain arsenic from grapes that were grown in chemically-fertilized soil (fertilizers often contain arsenic).

8. Propylene Glycol

Found in the popular beer Corona, propylene glycol (PEG) is known to cause neurological conditions. It may be in other beers, too; the problem, of course, is that there’s no way to know unless the manufacturer chooses to list ingredients.

That brings us to the question of…

What To Drink?

As mentioned above, always purchase alcoholic beverages in glass bottles to avoid harmful BPA.

When it comes to wine, choose organic whenever possible. If you have access to local wines from smaller wineries, that’s also a viable choice. If those are unobtainable, there’s little harm in drinking wine in moderation, because the study applied the EPA standard of drinking water to wine, which is consumed much more infrequently than water.

The same is true for beer. Organic beers are the healthier choice, but if those are unobtainable, the next best option are beers from small local craft brewers. Also, because of their strict beer purity law, known as Reinheitsgebot, all German beers contain no added chemicals which make them a viable option. Additionally, the following beers are known to be free of the toxic ingredients listed above:

  • Sierra Nevada
  • Amstel
  • Heineken

As far as liquor goes, choose organic as well. But if that is not an option, tequila is considered one of the “cleanest” alcoholic beverages, and is generally very low in toxins. Be sure to select tequila that includes some variation of the words “100% agave” on its label.

As you choose which alcoholic beverages to drink, remember to consume them in moderation. The typical recommendation is one five-ounce glass of wine or one 12-ounce beer a day for women and two for men. More than that, and you could run the risk of harming your liver. In fact, even consuming one drink a day within the recommended limits can tax your liver if you’re drinking beverages that contain any of the toxins listed above.

Here’s why this happens. Your liver treats alcohol – more specifically ethanol – like it does fat, so the broken down metabolic by-products get converted into fatty acids by the enzyme alcohol dehydrogenase. The fatty acids are stored in the liver and in other tissues. Additionally, it takes time for the liver to process the alcohol (about 1/3 of an ounce per hour), so drinking a lot at a fast pace can cause significant damage, including the death of liver cells and various alcohol-related diseases, such as:

  • Fatty liver disease
  • Hepatitis
  • Cirrhosis

These and other alcohol-related liver damage can be avoided by drinking in moderation, choosing toxin-free beverages, and periodically cleansing your liver.

Cleanse Your Liver In Just One Week

It only takes one week for the Osteoporosis Fresh Start Cleanse to free your liver from its toxic load. This helps to jump-start the bone building process, as a functional liver is crucial for bone health. If your liver is damaged or simply not up to par, then toxins will accumulate in your system. These poisons are highly acidifying and accelerate bone loss.

Also, a healthy liver is required for the manufacture and proper performance of bone-building Vitamin D and bone alkaline phosphatase, which aids osteoblasts in their bone-building role.

Accelerated Bone Remodeling In Just 7 Days!

Discover how the Osteoporosis Fresh Start Cleanse can flush osteoporosis drugs and other bone-damaging toxins from your system – in just seven days.

Learn More Now →

So to protect your liver and your bones, it’s a good idea to “pamper” your liver periodically. The Osteoporosis Fresh Start Cleanse is an effective way to do just that. Some cleanses require expensive supplements and other specialized products, but the Osteoporosis Fresh Start Cleanse doesn't, and it's a downloadable file that you can conveniently access any time you want to “treat” your liver to a restful cleanse.

So go ahead and enjoy healthful alcoholic beverages in moderation – now you know how to choose the bone-healthiest options.



1 Kwon, Soon Kil, et al. “Ethanol Induced Urine Acidification is Related with Early Acetaldehyde Concentration.” Kidney Research and Clinical Practice. 33. 2. (2014): A6. Web. July 18, 2016. https://www.krcp-ksn.com/article/S2211-9132(14)00058-8/abstract

The Top 14 Things You’re Doing That Are Damaging Your Bones... And More!

  • Stop The Bone Thieves! report
  • Email course on how to prevent and reverse bone loss
  • Free vital osteoporosis news and updates.
Get It Free Now
12 comments. Leave Yours Now →
  1. Jason

    Your list of recommended beers to drink contradicts the findings published……
    Heineken has been found to have pesticides / chemicals.

    Not sure i can trust what you’re publishing!

  2. Ruben

    Been following for years.
    Thank you so much for all you do.


  3. Jackie Molloy

    Has anybody had joint replacement surgery while still battling osteoporosis? I’ve started working on Vivian’s program, but haven’t had a bone scan lately, so I don’t know where I am with that. I’ve got major damage to my shoulder joint and have to have it totally replaced. Will it work with osteo?

  4. Laura

    Is seltzer acidifying? It doesn’t list phosphorus, like flavored sodas that have sugar.

  5. renee

    Is the Osteo Cleans book, vegan recipes?

  6. TGrace Aisuisu

    Thanks for the information the best option is to abstain

  7. Pat

    This is a great article. I was particularly interested in the paragraph with fermentation and am wondering what your take is on fermented foods and Kombucha. Thank you.


    • Vivian Goldschmidt, MA

      Hi Pat,

      Fermented foods are alkalizing and bone-healthy due to the presence of beneficial microbes. 🙂

  8. Letizia Seirup

    This is so confusing and misleading: what about the wines that are not made in the US which is widely drunk and is subject to a completely different set of rules and regulations?
    You give no useful information here, except the usual scary recommendation we have heard for decades about wine and alcohol…

  9. Linda

    Also what about apple cider ales, such as Angry Orchard or Woodchuck?

    • Vivian Goldschmidt, MA

      Hi Linda,

      The same criteria would hold true for these types of drinks as well – look for organic options, check ingredients, and don’t hesitate to research specific brands to see if they are “clean.”

  10. Pnorymen

    How about Stella Artois?

Leave a Comment

The purpose of this comment section is to encourage you to interact with the other Savers. Thank you so much for joining the conversation!

Get Started With Your FREE
Natural Bone Building Kit.

Get a free copy of our ‘Stop The Bone Thieves’ eBook, exclusive content that you can’t find anywhere else, plus vital osteoporosis news and updates.

Get It Free

Get Your Free Bone-Building Kit


‘Stop The Bone Thieves’ guide, exclusive info, plus vital osteoporosis news and updates.