Rice is a staple of many cuisines across the globe. Most people keep a bag on hand for everything from casseroles and curries to a simple side dish.
But did you know that rice contains traces of inorganic arsenic?1 While the levels might not be high enough to make you sick, arsenic has a negative impact on the bone remodeling process and your overall health.
Today we'll learn about arsenic and rice, including which types of rice are the safest, and how to reduce the arsenic levels. You'll also get a delicious rice-based recipe to try at home.
Arsenic And Bone Health
When you hear the word arsenic, it might bring to mind an Agatha Christie novel about murder by poison. But a little detective work will reveal that arsenic turns up in the real world more often than you might think. Scientific studies have linked the element to bone loss.
Researchers in Taiwan studied the effects of arsenic-contaminated drinking water on rats and on osteoblasts in samples of rat bone cells. Osteoblasts are cells that secrete the matrix for bone formation- they literally build your bones.
The rats exposed to the contaminated water experienced a loss of bone mineral density and degradation of bone microstructure. The bone cell samples offered an explanation: the arsenic inhibited osteoblast differentiation.2
Studies with human participants who have experienced chronic arsenic exposure arrived to the same conclusion: arsenic causes bone loss, leading to osteopenia, osteoporosis, and a higher risk of fracture.3
Studies on mouse bone cells found that arsenic inhibits the differentiation of osteoblasts (the cells that build new bone), and causes bone loss. Studies with human participants concluded the same.
The Wide (And Wild) World Of Rice
There are many types of rice grown all around the world, but when discussing arsenic levels, there are usually only a few major categories considered. We'll outline those varieties, as well as a few other widely cultivated types.
The anatomy of a grain of rice will help to make sense of how these types differ. There's one part of a rice grain that is always removed: the husk. This outer layer protects the inner part that we eat.
Beneath the husk is a layer called the bran. The bran is a nutritious coating that gives many types of rice their distinctive color. The bran is why brown rice is brown, black rice is black, and so on.
The germ is a nutrient-dense kernel that often contributes to the color of a grain of rice. It is present in whole grain rice.
Finally, the innermost meat of a grain of rice is the endosperm, but you might recognize it as simply white rice. Rice is most commonly consumed in this stripped-down form. Any type of rice available as white rice also exists as whole grain, or brown, rice– although not every variety of rice is commonly sold in its whole grain form.
Now that you know a little about the structural elements of a grain of rice, here are some of the most common varieties:
- Basmati – This slender long-grain rice grown in the Himalayan foothills is widely used in Indian, Pakistani, and Middle-Eastern cuisines. Basmati rice can be found as brown rice, with its bran intact, or as white rice, if it has been milled to remove the bran layer.
- Jasmine – This variety of long-grain rice is known (and named) for its slightly floral aroma when cooked. A common ingredient in Thai cuisines, it can be found as both white and wholegrain.
- American long-grain rice – This versatile rice is a favorite around the world. Its extra-long grains can be purchased with the bran intact as whole-grain, or milled to a faster cooking white rice, or prepared as the fastest cooking from, “easy-cook” or “converted” rice.
- Arborio – This medium grain rice is the most popular risotto rice, native to Italy. Its high starch content creates a creamy consistency when cooked. Arborio rice is almost always sold as white rice since this form creates the creamiest texture.
- Black rice – Varieties of black rice include Thai black rice, Nerone black rice, and Venere black rice, all of which are whole grain and high in fiber.
- Japanese or sushi rice – This short-grain rice is a staple of Japanese cooking and is usually white rice.
- Wild rice – This rice is actually a seed of a strain of aquatic grass grown primarily in North America. The grains are long, thin and black or brown in color. This flavorful, nutty rice has a chewy outer layer and is rich in protein and antioxidants.
Rice that has had its bran layer removed is white rice, and rice with the bran layer is whole grain rice that is usually brown, black, or another hue. Jasmine, Basmati, and American long-grain rice are some of the most common varieties, commonly available as both white and brown rice.
Arsenic Levels In Rice
Unfortunately, rice typically absorbs arsenic from the environment during the growing process.
However, not all rice contains the same amount, and there are several factors that weigh into the arsenic levels of rice. Tests by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and independent research published by Consumer Reports and scientific journals provide information about arsenic levels.
In 2014, Consumer Reports tested 128 samples of basmati, jasmine, and sushi rice for arsenic. The researchers then combined the results with findings from their 2012 tests and the FDA’s analysis of arsenic in rice for a total of 697 samples.3
They found the biggest discrepancies were between white and brown rice, and between different geographical sources. Here is a summary of their findings:4
- Overall, brown rice was found to have 80% more arsenic than white rice of the same type.
- White basmati rice from California, Pakistan, and India, and sushi rice from the U.S. had, on average, about half of the amount of arsenic found in most other types of rice.
- Brown basmati from California, Pakistan, or India had about one third less arsenic than brown rice from other places.
- All types of rice (except sushi and quick-cooking) from parts of the US other than California (including Arkansas, Louisiana, and Texas) had the highest levels of arsenic. White rice from California had 36% less arsenic than white rice from other parts of the country.
- Other grains tested, such as amaranth, quinoa, buckwheat, millet, polenta, bulgur, barley, and farro, contained very little arsenic.
This data suggests that brown rice always poses a greater bone health risk, but in a study that examined the absorption rates of arsenic from brown and white rice using urinary analysis, researchers concluded that the arsenic in brown rice is less bioavailable than in white rice. (Bioavailability describes how effectively the body absorbs a substance.) Brown rice contains more total arsenic than white, so the amount of arsenic absorbed from eating white and brown rice is very nearly equal.5
The urinary analysis study is not conclusive, but it does suggest that brown versus white rice might not be as important as the geographic source when it comes to minimizing arsenic consumption.
The good news is that you can reduce the arsenic content of rice by applying a simple treatment before you cook it. Always try to buy rice with the lowest possible amount of arsenic, but no matter what type of rice you're cooking, or where its from, use these four simple steps to lower your intake of arsenic:
- First, rinse your rice well
- Next put it in a pot and cover with water
- Bring it to a boil, then boil for 5 minutes
- Drain it, then cook your rice with fresh water following package directions
Don't forget that all types of rice are acidifying. While brown grain rice is a good source of bone-healthy nutrients such as fiber and manganese (and is a Foundation Food because of it), it must be balanced with alkalizing foods.
Data analysis shows that regardless of the type, rice grown in India, Pakistan, and the state of California contain the lowest levels of arsenic. Generally, brown rice contains more arsenic than white rice, but that difference might be rendered insignificant by the lower bioavailability of the arsenic in brown rice. Rinsing your rice, boiling it for five minutes, then draining and cooking with fresh water will reduce arsenic content.
A Rice Dish You Don't Want To Miss
Serve this delicious alkalizing recipe on top of rice.
- 1 small onion, diced
- 2 cloves garlic, minced
- 2 large sweet potatoes, diced into 1/2-inch cubes (preferably peeled)
- 1 carrot, sliced into thin rounds
- 1 zucchini, diced
- 1 cup of green beans, chopped
- 1 tsp coconut oil
- 1/4 tsp turmeric
- 1/3 cup coconut milk or almond milk
- 1 cup of vegetable stock or plain water (adjust for desired consistency)
- 1 cup of cooked chickpeas
- 2 teaspoons lemon juice
- 1 1/2 teaspoons of curry powder (adjust to taste)
- Sea salt to taste
- Start by heating the oil in a saute pan. Add the onions and saute over medium heat until they begin to sweat and turn translucent. Next, add the turmeric and garlic and stir-fry for 30 seconds.
- Then add the carrots and sweet potatoes– season lightly with salt and cover the pan. Turn the heat to low and cook the veggies for around five minutes. Add some water if they start to stick.
- Add the zucchini and green beans with a half cup of water or vegetable stock. Cover and cook five more minutes.
- If the sweet potatoes aren't cooked, let them stay on a few more minutes.
- Once they're cooked, stir in the chickpeas, curry powder, and another half cup of vegetable stock and bring the mixture to a boil.
- Now add the milk and allow the curry to heat through, but don't let it reach a boil. Turn off the heat, then stir in the lemon juice.
- Serve hot with rice.
What This Means To You
Rice can provide valuable nutrients, and by choosing rice from a region that produces rice with low arsenic content, and using the arsenic reduction technique you learned today, you can ensure that you're protecting your bones while you nourish your body.
As always, there is strength in variety. Since all rice contains arsenic, you should eat a variety of other whole grains in addition to rice to reduce the amount of arsenic you consume.
Even if you never ate a grain of rice, you would still be exposed to arsenic in other foods, water, and the environment.
Minimizing your intake of toxins is essential. That is why the Save Institute developed a simple seven-day cleanse that gives your body a chance to detox from all those toxins from your system. The Osteoporosis Fresh Start Cleanse fast tracks your body's ability to heal itself and grow stronger, higher quality bones. Try it twice a year to help your body battle the chemicals and toxins that threaten your bone health.
Accelerated Bone Remodeling In Just 7 Days!
Discover how the Osteoporosis Fresh Start Cleanse can flush osteoporosis drugs and other bone-damaging toxins from your system – in just seven days.
Comments on this article are closed.
For some reason, I’m sensitive to most all the varieties of grains and very often end up with a bad headache after eating them. Over the years I’ve found about 99% of the time I don’t get headaches from eating Bob’s Red Mill Brown Rice Farina hot cereal. The arsenic has probably accumulated over many years somewhat in my system. I’m trying to skip a day about once a week and eat eggs and potatoes, which also give me head aches if I have them more than once a week.
I asked my Internist and he said he would not worry about it, and he eats lots of rice too. For some of us, there seems no alternatives. I’ve tried all the grains out there from the health food store. I’m just commenting that this can be difficult for some of us, as much of the food you say is proper to eat causes some of us pain. I continue to look into this and hope to try something called “Food enzyme with ox bile” Can you comment on this? I’m thinking maybe if my digestion works better, it’ll help me not have all those headaches.
I read a book by a researcher /doctor that apricot kernels contain ‘natural ‘ arsenic and B 17, which the writer said prevents cancer. He recommends eating up to 30 apricot kernels a day – if recovering from cancer. I bought a packet at a health store but as a healthy person, have wondered if it is advisable to eat them at all…
Would that arsenic be the same kind that is found in the rice ?
Thank you for this information on rice types and how to remove their arsenic content.
I always soak my brown rice for some time before cooking, then throw away the soaking water and cook the rice with fresh water. Would this have the same effect as the 5 minute boiling method that you describe?
Thank you for all the useful information!
When I mentioned the “quick-cooking” brown rice, I forgot to mention that it is already “parboiled” and is done in five minutes. So does that cancel boiling the rice again before cooking? Thanks.
My rice cooker operates on the amount of water it contains. Is there
an adaptation based on boiling rice for five minutes first?
Thanks for your very thorough and insightful articles. Can regular cow
milk be used for almond or soy?
Thanks For Your Help
I was diagnosed with Osteopenia, and my doctor suggested supplementing with 1000mgs Vitamin D, and 500-1000mgs Calcium. Is vitamin D3 okay to take? Also, where do I find organic calcium?
Will it be labeled as organic calcium? Thank you Vivian, I follow you for many years 🙂
The Lundberg rice is said to have the lowest amount of arsenic.
Also would germination remove the arsenic?
Thank you, Ita.
I’ve been been using long-grain quick-cooking brown rice lately for convenience mostly. Do I need to rinse the rice before using? Is this the safer option and just as healthy for nutrients?
I notice there is no mention of Australia in your article, yet we grow different types of rice as well. Do you have information you can share about our rice please?
I’ve noticed your choice of milk is almond. I use lite Soy milk with added calcium. I’ve compared the two & Soy milk seems to have more calcium generally. Should I be drinking Almond milk for my bones?
Thank you for this insightful article and how arsenic can be minimized in the rice we cook.
As a dietitian….I am really impressed with the great information provided by save our ones.
Loved the information about the rice didn’t know to cook it twice.
Question about MCT OIL is it good for your bones if it is any suggestions what should I be looking for. Thanks, Roberta